Thursday, 25 June 2020

Sensei sensori

Seven years ago I drove in the dark through storm and flood to watch Jiro Dreams of Sushi - a documentary about Ono Jiro 小野 二郎 [family name first] who had been working in the restaurant trade for - - - 70 years. Here's a short tributary in which the master of the old school meets René Redzepi, the creator of Noma, a restaurant in Copenhagen [Sunday Supplement] that has twice been voted Restaurant of the Universe by the Inner Circle of Foodies. I'm not a foodie like Dau.II is  Foodie but on some level I recognise the parallels between lab-bench and counter-top. One common feature is the value of A Good Pair of Hands that person who can let their hands do the working without constantly thinking about what's going on. AGPoH is also important in drumming. I am the antithesis of AGPoH but I come closest to that state of being when I'm cooking: it's not reproducible but mmmmm is it good.

My Lockdown foodie book has been Hungry by Jeff Gordinier; its subtitle is Eating road-tripping and risking it all with Rene Redzepi the greatest chef in the World.  I'm not sure I would have gotten round to it if the loan period had been three weeks. I'm glad I was given the extra time, because it's an interesting saga about how a grown man with two children and a breaking marriage becomes a total groupie for an Albanian/Danish cook . . . and haemorrhages a lot of money to hang with his guru in Mexico, New York, Sydney, Norway and Denmark.

It's a genre in't it? Eat Pray Love was about a rich white woman who found that money can't buy everything anything that seems worth striving for. That went viral, was made into a film and made the author another fortune. Then there was Bill Buford's Heat [reviewed here as Heat Braise Shanks] where another Inner Circle journalist goes off to find himself in the white heat of someone else's kitchen. I'm ambivalent about these people. They can't keep their marriage on the rails but can career off in wild directions to find their true selves. otoh, why must we expect them to like the hand of cards dealt to them by fate and circumstance? Isn't it better to have an epiphany like Bill Bryson realising that he should have been born in Europe; or Niall Deacon parking sheep-farming to be a stone-mason? This is what you are likely to be presented with at Noma:
Call me conventional, but I think I'll stick to the traditional recipe for spotted dick.

René Redzepi is neat because he is clearly Out There when it come to giving something a Why not? whirl. Forget slavishly following in the footsteps of Escoffier and doing things because it's always been done this way.  Previously unexploited molluscs and crustaceans get air-freighted from Norway to be plated with ant confit and trout swim-bladders. The expense is "exclusive" and so the only way you and me are going to get a sniff is to sign up as a scullion. But bring your ladle, because you'll need to fight off a score of hungry wannabe plongeurs who would gladly fill your toque.  And Gordinier's book? It's okay, when you get past the self-pity and the eye-watering cost of pushing the foodie envelope.


Wednesday, 24 June 2020

The game the whole family can play

Georges Cuvier stoutly maintained that from a single bone, he could extrapolate an entire animal. From an entire skeleton you can infer a lot about the ecological niche its owner inhabited. It's a bit of an ask to go directly from the bone to the biome, because two layers of descriptive fuzziness = noise. I've done my bit [over about 30 years] of reading meaning into DNA sequences [recent - previs - elvis] not all of it frivolous.  But there is a whole level on additional "good pair of hands" skills required to generate new sequence data from really old, poorly conserved, fragmented DNA from bones which have been quietly degrading for thousands of years.  It is amazing that it can be done at all, let alone that the data can reveal expansive insights into the life and times of our ancestors.

An eye opening new paper from Lara Cassidy et al. Dan Bradley is shining a light on the DNA of long dead inhabitants of Ireland. It has required mastery of the three key skills 1) meticulously polished, ultra-careful clean-room technique and 2) a whole other set of skills in computational sequence analysis and 3) appropriate choice of multivariate statistics. Since I last wrote about The Effective = 1st author on this paper  [prev] , she has applied for, and accepted, a lectureship in her once-and-future department. It's super nice to launch her "grown-up" career with the front cover of Nature [R]; like, no pressure for future delivery!

There's a lot to unpack in the paper and most of the technical details [at all levels: ancient DNA abstraction; sequencing and assembly of ancient genomes; statistical analysis of the data] will be beyond my pay-grade. It's beyond the Nature pay-wall as well, so inaccessible to Joe Public. You may therefore choose to jump to the accompanying News&Views Exec Summary by Alison Sheridan of Scots Nat Museum.

There are three neat findings.

1) The salacious one which has made the headlines is the fact that one of ancient corpses, buried in the centre of Newgrange, in the centre of Brú na Bóinne was the product of a brother-sister union. This is the only rational explanation for the fact that long tracts of his genome are identical on both copies of his chromosomes aka heterozygosity = 0:
But the singular of data is anecdote and, notwithstanding the later Pharaohs, there is no justification for saying, from this one case, that incest was an essential bonk in dynastic politics of Neolithic Ireland. You could equally well suggest that Down's syndrome [see para below] was running at 1-out-of-50 = 2% of the population in the same era; instead of 0.1% as now.

2) The second finding hinges on a neat analysis to determine the sex of the bone/tooth fragments from which the DNA was obtained. Modern high-throughput DNA sequencing makes a helluva lot of short 'reads' and then uses a big lump of a computer to line up the overlaps into 'contigs' which in turn can be mapped to The Human Genome to reveal their chromosomal location. The raw read-count for the X chromosome can be compared to read-count for the other chromosomes if the X reads are the same density then you have a XX female if X reads are ½ as dense as the rest then it's a boy. I don't know whether the data shouted out or if some bright spark decided to look but one of the ancient dead had 1.5x reads for Chromosome 21whish indicates trisomy 21 aka The Down's. That boy never grew up to adulthood, but nor was he smothered at birth; and he was buried in a place of honour.

3) The third extrapolatory finding is an analysis of the isotopes of nitrogen and carbon to infer whether there was meat in the diet. There are 2 stable isotopes of carbon: C12 makes of 99% of natural samples and C13 contributes the rest. C14, used in carbon dating, decays radioactively and is registered only as 'trace'. But that trace has a half-life of 5,730 years which is neatly in the range to calibrate the age of the samples under investigation. Likewise there are two stable nitrogen isotopes except that the minor species is even less common N14 makes of 99.4%  N15 makes up the rest. I'll have to take it on trust that [relatively] high N15 and low C13 indicates a high protein meat diet. The Dublin consortium are happy to associate this diet with high status, although I bet that there were poachers on the royal estates who ate nothing but beef or salmon like former day Irish wedding guests.

Bonus. 4) There's an interesting twist in the N&V. Dr Sheridan is a trad-trained archaeologist who is inclined to dismiss the Cassidy/Bradley best-guess DNA evidence that the incommming high-status agriculturalists, who occupied these elaborate tombs, came from Spain. " . . . the authors seem to fall into the trap of assuming that Ireland’s farmers had sailed up from Iberia — an argument for which there is no archaeological evidence. Instead, the archaeology points towards the Morbihan area of Brittany in northwest France . . .". But Sheridan is possibly clinging to the wreckage of what she learned in grad school and out in the field. DNA has the capacity to sweep all those pot-sherds and digs into the dustbin of history. When Des Higgins asserted that DNA said that whales were a rather specialised artiodactyl his hypothesis was greeted with derision but the deriders were wrong.

Finally, as everyone is talking incest, there will be snitty comments about Dr Cassidy, having done her stellar PhD under the supervision of Prof Bradley, has been parachuted into the newly available lectureship in Bradley's department. But as Freud said, "sometimes a cigar is just a cigar"; it's not useful to over-analyse things. Sometimes the very best is right in front of you and there's nothing to be gained by looking over her shoulder to sweep further and fare worse. There is luck involved, of course, but it's only in the timing which has yielded to proactive serendipity; Cassidy, like my mother, has made her own luck.

Tuesday, 23 June 2020

Dry heath

It's a biome! Dry heath is an intermediate stage in ecological succession; where well-drained soil is paused in its journey to becoming a real grown-up forest. This adolescence may be extended for decades if someone runs a bunch of sheep across the landscape and they nibble nibble to scarf up any wannabe trees before they become saplings. The Red Hill, for which our townland is named, is 200 ha. in extent and owned in common by ~20 shareholders. The Department of Agriculture and their puppet-masters in Brussels are interested in doing something different and potentially more productive with Ireland's uplands. On their watch, the foolish application of policies and subsidies has seen the wholesale degradation of the habitat by undergrazing; overgrazing, poaching, soil-erosion; monoculture forestry with invasive species; turf-cutting, not turf-cutting; heather burning. Last year we-the-commoners became part of a pilot study to investigate other uses for the hill than running lean-and-hangry, almost feral, yellow-eyed monsters of the species Ovis aries. Pilot studies are too often driven by haven't-a-clue policy-makers; I suppose, in fairness if they had a clue, it wouldn't need a pilot study.

Whatevs, like. The upshot is that we are now well into our second year of drawing down money from The Man and so, maybe, are in a position to see if anything we did last year has had any impact on The Hill and/or the thinking at head office. I used to share a house with two long-haired botanists (and their long-haired cat) and let's say I was glad I never had to sleep on the dander sofa. But they were super-sound interesting blokes despite having been born across the water.  Project Repurpose has hired another exemplar of the Type, as The Ecologist. And last Saturday a couple of us went for a yomp up and round the hill with Tom the Plant to record the presence / absence of key species on the dry heath. So it was qualitative rather than quantitative research.

Dry heath is increasingly rare in Western Europe and nobody wants to see the last few patches of the stuff disappear under shopping-malls or hundreds of hectares of Sitka spruce Picea sitchensis. There are (at least) three sources of concern:
  • Succession, especially if the replacing trees are foreigners like Sitka spruce and Christmas tree Abies procera. A few hawthorn Crataegus monogyna, black-thorn Prunus spinosa, hazel Corylus avellana and willow Salix spp. can be tolerated for shelter and hedging. And native birch Betula pubescens because it is so pretty.
  • Bracken Pteridium aquilinum: unforgiving competitor for light and nutrients during the Summer. Dangerous in July when they produce carcinogenic spores. Full of toxic secondary compounds, so it's a good thing that sheep refuse to eat the stuff.
  • Too much spiny gorse Ulex europaeus which can grow to impenetrable thickets, excluding or entangling sheep and forming a potential fire-hazard. Small quantities tolerated for day-brightening coconutty blossom and as a source of kindling
This [above looking southeast towards the plains of Wexford] is what we found.
  • The three heathers [all you need to know about the blooming heather, go lassie go]
    • Erica cinerea Bell Heather Fraoch Cloigíneach 
    • Erica tetralix Cross-leaved Heath Fraoch Naoscaí 
    • Calluna vulgaris Ling Fraoch Mór 
  • Other shrubberies
    • Ulex gallii Western gorse native to Ireland desirable indicator species
    • Ulex europaeus Whin/Gorse/Furze/Bushes invasive in blow
    • Vaccinium myrtillus blueberry/bilberry Fraochán [prev] 100 years ago the fraocháns was a big money-spinner for cash-poor families in the Blackstairs - read the book.
  • Sedges
    • Trichophorum cespitosum deergrass  Cíb cheanngheal 
    • Eriophorum angustifolium Cottongrass Ceannbhán
    • Schoenus nigricans Black Bog-rush Sifín
  • Forbs
    • Galium saxatile heath bedstraw Luibh na bhfear gonta [wounded man's herb for its supposed antiseptic qualities]
    • Potentilla erecta tormentil Néalfartach 
    • Stellaria holostea stitchwort Tursarraing mhór
    • Hyacinthoides non-scripta bluebell Coinnle corra [prev]
    • Pedicularis sylvatica lousewort Lus an ghiolla
    • Oxalis acetosella wood sorrel Seamsóg [prev]
    • Polygala serpyllifolia heath milkwort Na deirfiúríní
Tom the Plant needed to record at least 10 of a short list of species indicative / diagnostic of dry heath. He was 9 out of 10 within 500m and 40 minutes of opening the mountain gate, so that ticked the boxes. But he confessed to getting a proper education in the Blackstairs project because every commonage was different and everyone was good. And while identifying and preserving "dry heath" habitat had been a significant driver of the funding, "dry heath" was as hard to grasp and tie down as running water. All that book-l'arnin' was grand but the reality on the side of a blustery south-facing hillside in SE Ireland made for a lot of exceptions. Then again, those names put on biomes do have a predictive quality: if you find tormentil hugging the ground near a bunch of heather you'll be able to make money betting to find heath bedstraw within 5m.

Monday, 22 June 2020

What's DNA to him?

What makes a family? It's partly about genes-in-common but it's much more about shared experience. After all IF you're going to claim that a gay couple with an adopted kid are not a family because none of them have a recent common ancestor THEN you may leave The Blob now. Even if they don't explicitly recall that time Mam, two sherries down, dropped Christmas turkey on the kitchen floor; they will build up their own version of the family's shared experience. In families, we train each other up to respond in particular and peculiar ways to internal and external events and thereby become a more cohesive unit. Even if those internal events are horribly dark, they shape the participants so that they look and feel more like each other than they do to outsiders.

When our kids were small, I'd set up an age-appropriate Treasure Hunt for Easter Sunday morning. Looking back on some of the clues, I marvel at my concept of age-appropriate because I seem to have had absurdly high expectations for what a 9 and 7 y.o. were able for. Then again, then again; it was usual for them to rattle through the puzzles quick enough to satisfy their chocolate acquisition drives, with only minimal supplementary clues from me. I suppose I was exercising my educational philosophy of pushing them a little bit more than they might have been initially comfortable with. I reckon a large part of it was that continued practice tuned them into my ways of seeing so it became steadily easier to read me like a book.

That's all by way of scene-setting for the bday card I received last week from Gdau.I, who is 8 going on 800. Never underestimate how much knowledge pre-teen kids are packing away. The classics quiz I sent her back-at-you was in response to one she set her parents and grandparents. The grandfathers scored 3/10 and 2/10 respectively while the parents mustered 0/10 and 1/10. Adult honour was marginally restored when Dau.I the Reader clocked up 7/10. I won the Junior Scripture Prize aged 11 because I read, with care and attention, 6 chapters of the KJV of the bible every week for about 24 months.  The card [L] is clearly a cartoon of the iconic DNA double helix; but Gdau.I had helpfully included a key on the reverse. Adenine - Guanine - Thymine - Cytosine . . . well, kidder, that's life, Jim, but not as we know it. Because although you have been careful to maintain consistency in the pairings, all the life on this planet pairs A with T rather than A with C. But that's okay because it gives more options on what the message encoded in the picture might be.

Q. What's DNA to me?
A. It must be a clue to a puzzle!
Because I refused to accept that an 8 y.o. would stick just random base-pairs in her double helix. As you shd know, DNA is read off in triplets = codons using a particular [almost] Universal Genetic Code, but it's not obvious from picture what is the direction of transcription and translation. So there are 4 different ways in which the DNA bases can read: blue up; blue down; red up; red down. There are also one or two points of ambiguity where the turns of the helical backbones obscure the base-pairs between them. But here's the data transliterated:
CG?TATAGCTA?TC
AT?GCGCTAGC?GA
CT?ATCGATAT?GC
AG?CGATCGCG?TA
It is obvious, with a bit of help from ExPaSy's translate tool which is the information-containing strand and its direction (the others are random noise):
CTaATCGATATcGC. where I have interpolated (a c) for the backbone-obscured bases
 L  I  D  I  A
Lidia? It's a message! From one generation to its ancestor!! But what can it mean? there are a number of possibilities:
  1. A command to go forthwith to Kyrgyzstan to find an Asian dwarf spider.
  2. A suggestion that I should squeeze into my Traje des Luces [example R] <eeee but I do love some skin-tight sequins> to fight Un Toro de Lidia.
    • I can't believe she advises such a dangerous escapade in my declining years . . .  unless she hopes to inherit my Traje before I'm quite ready to let it go
  3. It is a heads up that the child has acquired a tat. Not my business but I'm cool with that, so long as it isn't on her forehead. I'm also okay with modest metallic appendages in children - ear-rings etc.

Sunday, 21 June 2020

Summer Solstice Sunday

Gdau.I has been mad about Greek Mythology for the last year or two, in the way that other kids of similar age might be mad about dinosaurs . . . or Barbie-dolls. She sent the family out a quiz last week with 10 questions about the ancient greeks and their stories. I did woefully, scraping a bare 2/10 right. Then again, at least 4 of the questions I was pretty certain I'd never known the answer. It was the other four which niggled, because when I was her age, I'd been quite interested / knowledgeable in the field.  One of those edge of consciousness question s was "Who tamed Pegasus [the winged 'orse]?  As I dredged the dark reaches of distant memory the word Bellerophon surfaced but I batted that down with naaah that was Napoleon's horse assuming that the retrieval 'bots were just popping up any old nag. I was wrong on several levels:
  • Bellerophon Βελλεροφόντης was indeed the chap who, the help of a magic bridle, tamed and rode Pegasus
  • Belleraphon was not Napoleon's horse - that was called Marengo
  • But Bellerophon is in the same room of the memory palace because after the disaster at Waterloo, Napoleon acknowledged that the game was up and surrendered to the nearest British warship which was HMS Bellerophon, Captain Maitland [bloboprev on the "Billy Ruffian"].
In the course of my scraping the barrel of my memory, I recalled Bucephalus Βουκεφάλας [begins withh B; is Alexander the Great's horse] and Copenhagen: Wellington's horse at Waterloo. He was up top when Henry Paget lost his leg.  Having washed up in København, it seems meet to hang out there for a bit

Saturday, 20 June 2020

Chocolate Fudge Cake

Just a perfick day. My birthday, Wednesday, was, like the electron, a bi-locating affair.  The Beloved and I spent the morning pootling about in the garden - a lot of shovelling compost and transporting water - and then set off for Costa na Déise to start a week of caring for Pat the Salt my venerable F-in-L. After a thanksgiving dinner that couldn't be beat we all set to on a generous tranche of of the pictured cake . . . with a few tart strawberries as counterpoint. But Pat goes to bed early, whatever the state of light beyond the window so I was able to escape for a yomp along the beach at Kilfarrasy.
As I haven't gotten my toes salt-wet since the beginning of March, I was delighted with myself.

On going to bed in daylight; my mother maintained that she never taught her children how to tell the time so that she could hoosh us off to bed when she had had enough.
"But can't we stay out a little longer? Vitamin D is still a-makin'"
"Nope, it's bed o'clock; I'll read you a story"

Friday, 19 June 2020

Anybody out there?

A few years ago, I wrote about the Drake Equation, one attempt at guesstimating whether we are all alone in the Universe or if there are intelligent beings out beyond the solar system with whom we could converse. I wouldn't be much of a dialogue because the nearest star is Alpha Centauri and that's 4.2 light years [same as radio-wave years] away. Ask a question like "Have you discovered Thorium?" or "Is DNA at all relevant to your lifestyle?" and, even having sorted out the language of communications, it's going to be 8.4 years before you get an answer back. It is evens probable that there's a planet orbiting one of the suns of the Alpha Centauri system and that the planet is in the Goldiloxian 'habitable zone': not too close and torrid or so far as to be frigid.

I was tooling about The Déise yesterday and caught Newstalk FM with Sean Moncrieff interviewing one of the team from Nottingham who have re-jigged the Drake Equation to come up with their best guess about the likelihood of Intelligent Life "out there". Despite repeating the name of the interviewee, I was unable to recall it 30 minutes later when I'd stopped driving and was able to pick up a pencil. I did, however, remember their number of habitable planets with intelligent life that hadn't yet blown itself to buggery or asset-stripped their home to an uninhabitable cinder. So I googled "Nottingham 36" and found a) Bus #36 serves the Queen's Medical Centre, whither my boss decamped in 1993 leaving me i/c bioinformatics infrastructure Ireland at INCBI b) the authors of the habitable planets paper "The Astrobiological Copernican Weak and Strong Limits for Intelligent Life" were Tom Westby and Christopher Conselice. What a crappy, keep the proles at bay, title for a paper of such galaxial importance. The Copernican Principle is the idea of human non-exceptionalism: just because we are the only speaking, dancing, technologically capable species we know doesn't mean that we are specially created by a [beneficent] god. It's much more likely [regression to the mean etc.] that we are just about average

What Westby & Conselice [and Drake] are trying to do is have a punt at the number Communicating Extra-Terrestrial Intelligent civilizations (CETI) to establish a) whether it's worth looking for them b) whether any of them pose a threat, so we should worry about them. The answer is a clear nada, nix, zonders, furgeddit. Their key problem is trying to extrapolate a distribution of data points from a single case [humans [and dolphins] on Earth]. The media is predictably joyful about the proximity of "36" to Douglas Adams' Hitchhiker's "42" as the answer to the question "life, the universe and everything?".

W&C are much better informed than Drake on one aspect of the necessary conditions for intelligent life. Since the early 1900s, astrobiologists have been looking hard for planets orbiting around stars and now have 4,000-and-rising to choose from; with the discoveries doubling about every two years. The first was evidenced in 1994. And space-hero Sara Seagar has been designing nifty tech to help find more.

Anyway, that 36 comes with error bars: with all their assumptions and extrapolations or best-guesses, there could be as few as four [4!] CETIs in our galaxy or more than 200. But those are, if you pause your rubbish! button for a moment, really confident bounds on the limits of their calculations: only 2 orders of magnitude. As you have been told [I am careful not to use as you know because the numbers involved are waaaaay bigger than a breadbox and effectively incomprehensible] the galaxy has a great many stars but they are spread really thin: loads of space between them. Another view on the W&C numbers is that the average distance between CETI planets is ~17,000 light years. Even if we detect a signal, it will be such old news that we won't be able to respond appropriately. And if we're planning on sending out a signal telling our story, it seems unlikely that there will be anybody intelligent around to process the response.  All good fun, though, or at least "Mostly Harmless"