Tuesday, 14 July 2020

Alewife

I don't mind being wrong. Getting caught without pants is an object lesson in not being too snitty, snotty and certain in what I write. But really: twice in a week is making a bit of a pigpen out of  The Blob's signal-to-noise ratio. First I had to eat 'umble pie about my over-ethusiastic support for John Ioannidis' conclusions about the rate of Covid-19 positive in California. I know where that came from: my desire to flag the winner-takes-all way in which Coronarama is causing collateral deaths from undeclared coronary infarctions, and from parking breast-check, cervical screening and bowel-cancer surveys. Let alone my neighbour Liam who went into hospital for a diabetes episode, caught SARS-CoV2 and died with that 'existing condition'.

Then just at the end of last week, I had a go at Sara Baume for talking about anadromous herring: She: " . . . he remarks that there are fish who swim against the current - salmon and herring - who live in the open sea but are compelled to travel back to their rivers and streams to spawn"
Me: WTF!? Anadromous herring would be a first on this planet.

I'm glad my pal P from Massachusetts is a) awake b) reads The Blob c) knows about the alewife Alosa pseudoharengus which runs up many New England and Canadian rivers to spawn. This meant that she could pull me <tsk! tsk!> up on my error: because Alosa pseudoharengus is in the same family as Clupea harengus the Atlantic herring. Then again, fisherfolk have different common names for other [not anadromous] Clupeidae, as I acknowledged by in 2017: There is another species Clupea pallasii in the Pacific and the genus is related to sardines Sardina pilchardus, shad Alosa alosa and menhagen Brevoortia tyrannus all of which are hunted for food. Indeed the family Clupeidae comprises at least 200 named species. Which is all the more reason for using Linnaean binomers even in common discourse so everyone is on the same identification pages. Otherwise we're all Humpty-Dumpty in our discourse and nobody knows what? we're talking about. Bean there before with peas - igloos - fulmar - bergamot - bollix - lost in translation . . . mais revenons nous à nos gasperot:
Alewife [some of them above] were fantastically numerous when Europeans arrived in America 500 years ago. Maine lobster-fishers love to bait their pots with alewife partly because they can be scooped from the water by the basket [above]. The end of the Red Line on Boston's MBTA is called Alewife because the station is situated near Alewife Brook a tributary of the Mystic River [cue Van Morrison, why not?]. On toponymy Gaspereau Nova Scotia is named for the runs of Alosa pseudoharengus.

I met P when we were both in graduate school in Boston University in the 1980s. I was looking at the colonial history of New England and the Canadian Maritimes: tracing the waves of French, Dutch and English immigration through the genetic variation of present day domestic cats. It sounds unlikely, but the hypothesis turned out to have a surprising amount of internal consistency. I read a lot of books about 17thC colonial land-settlement, trade, commerce and agricultural practice. I was shocked to find that fish were so abundant that they were used as agricultural fertiliser which seemed completely arseways. A rich amino-acid-balanced source of animal protein, which could have fed the populace, was being used to grow a lysine-deficient sort of protein in corn Zea mays. Maize has to be grown and eaten with beans and squash to achieve a balanced diet. Alewife was particularly prized because it delivered itself inland during the spawning season and so saved on transport costs! As late as the 1880s 200,000 tonnes of fish was being rendered for oil and the dried carcasses being sold for fertiliser every year.

But before we get on our certainty horse to berate the rapacious exploitation of the natural world by The White Man, let's note that the idea of using fish for fertiliser was shared with the Puritans by Squanto their Native North American Liaison Officer NNALO. The local NNA name Munnawhatteaûg corrupted to menhaden, means literally 'fertilizer' (that which manures), "Afterwards they (as many as were able) began to plant ther corne, in which servise Squanto stood them in great stead, showing them both ye maner how to set it, and after how to dress & tend it. Also he tould them excepte they gott fish & set with it (in these old grounds) it would come to nothing, and he showed them yt in ye midle of Aprill they should have store enough come up ye brooke, by which they begane to build, and taught them how to take it, and wher to get other provissions necessary for them; all which they found true by triall & experience".

I had just finished beating <mea clupea mea clupea mea maxima clupea> mea breasta about anadromous alewifes when I picked up My Next Book David Cabot's 1100g weighty Ireland - a natural history. He washed up in Wexford in 1959 to start a BA in Natural History at TCD and never left. He got an Honorary Degree from TCD last year. In his book, he covers two other "herrings" which thrash up Irish rivers to spawn: allis shad Alosa alosa and twaite shad Alosa fallax. The latter is still to be caught at the head of the tide on the river Barrow at St Mullins. Well that was in 2015: maybe not so much now because twaite shad was 'vulnerable' on the 2011 NPWS RedList for Ireland; and the water quality on the Barrow hasn't gotten any better over the last decade. Alosa alosa is common enough in Europe but so rare in Irish waters that Red List labels it "data deficient". And the bottom line: a) there are anadromous herring if you define herring broadly and don't limit it to the kipper herring Clupea harengus, b) I was in error.

Monday, 13 July 2020

Thor woz right

One of the formative books of my sub-teen life, along with Triffids, was Thor Heyerdahl's Kon-Tiki: Across the Pacific in a Raft [Kon-Tiki ekspedisjonen]. The common theme is a self-sufficiency adventure involving a small group of people leaving the civilised masses behind. They made a film of the book a few years ago which was a fair telling of the story; and which we got to see.  I saw a 1:1 replica of Kon-Tiki [the original being destroyed in the climactic crash-landing] when I was teaching in Oslo in the late 90s.

Heyerdahl's theory was that South Americans had travelled across the Pacific to land on RapaNui  hundreds of years before Europeans had arrived to impose their name Easter Island. This outsider's theory was met with harrrmphing immediate dismissal by the anthropological inner circle, including my hero Wade Davis. Why, everyone knew that Polynesians had island-hopped their way from Asia to people pretty much every speck of dry-land in the vast wet stormy expanses of the Pacific Ocean.  Eee, they were quite cross. But distant drums of evidence have been accumulating that at least part of Heyerdahl's thesis is probably true. Chickens went East, sweet-potato Ipomoea went West. Some hold that Ipomoea made it without human help, like floating coconuts, but only Gary Larson could imagine Polynesian chickens in canoes [he hasn't yet].

One of the themes on The Blob is the rolling triumph of DNA evidence in shining light on the history of the world. There is a quiet sense of vindication for me because I spent 10 years of my early scientific life using [present day] genetics to trace the history of colonial migration in the 16thC and 17thC. Sequence analysis has shown that whales are streamlined hippos; there is more than one giraffe;  ditto elephant. The last 25 years has seen really careful lab work coupled with really nifty big-byte software develop a shining signal from really old, really degraded, really noisy, DNA samples. One of the drivers of the rise and focus of spotlight DNA is Dan Bradley at my Alma Mater Genetics TCD; most recently the bus has been in the capable hands of Lara Cassidy who has been revealing where Irish people are buried. At the end of June they were documenting incest and trisomy 23 in the ruling classes of Neolithic Ireland 5,000 years ago. The incest was revealed by showing longer chunks of similar DNA sequence than you'd expect if Mammy and Dad were unrelated.
Now, on the other side of the World, analysis of DNA extracted from present day inhabitants of Europe, South America and Polynesia is firming up the foundations [N&V] for Westwards travel in the Pacific. Title says it all: Native South Americans were early inhabitants of Polynesia. Heyerdahl's expedition was in the spirit of Elon Musk's SpaceX project: all ya gotta do is get there; getting back is a another day's work. It's looking a lot like there was traffic back and forth across the featureless ocean between the Marquesas, Rapa Nui and Colombia. The first author of the Nature paper Alexander G. Ioannidis is from Stanford; I can't easily establish if he's related to John Ioannidis [bloboprev] of the same institution.

The methods used by Ioannidis, A. and Andres Moreno for Pacific peopling are very similar to those of Cassidy and Bradley for Neolithic Ireland. These analyses are a bit above my simple-mind pay-grade but it looks like the granularity of the genomic chunks is key to determining how long ago they were "admixed".  For Ireland the sequence of brother and sister appear in long contiguous stretches across the chromosomes: that says 20 years of separation. In the Pacific they can date the timing of the arrival >!KaPooof!< of the first South American in the Marquesas to 800 years ago from the size of characteristic S.American DNA chunks. Intriguingly that's the best estimate of the time that Polynesians extended their range to Rapa Nui 3,000km south-by-east. These dates can be calibrated by the presence of larger lumps of European DNA in the plain people of Rapa Nui today. That cannot have happened before 1722. And in Rapa Nui, which was annexed by Chile in 1888, the genetic waters are further muddied by Native South American genes arriving with Chilean army conscripts.

Needless to say, there will be push-back from those who have a vested interest in tracing history by artefact, or language, or what they learned in graduate school 40 years ago. But, at least as part of an integrated platform involving trad archaeology,
DNA is The Future of The Past. 




Sunday, 12 July 2020

Miscellunday 11

Across the top:  sunnudag - sunnudagur - søndag - søndag - söndag - sunnuntai

Saturday, 11 July 2020

handiwork

My daughter the librarian sent me two books for my birthday in June; because she couldn't come visit during Coronarama. You may be sure that I would have preferred her company, with or without cake, that any amount of books. But it would be churlish not to read the books because I was in a pet and didn't get my druthers. The longer book is handiwork by Sarah Baume It wouldn't pass to call it a book of essays because the chunks are too short. Nothing as long as a single Blob here, for example. Then again, it's not a book of tweets or haiku either. It's sort of stream of consciousness from the year 2018 when Baume was putting together the makings of an exhibition of her hand-carved, hand-painted bird models.

Arty people in Ireland would probably know her written fiction better: Spill Simmer Falter Wither [Grauniad review] and A Line Made by Walking [Grauniad review]. There must be something there to get a respectful review of her first two books from the Arts Block in England. This new (2019) book shows that Baume is not just a crafter of words. The exhibition is of several dozen representations of birds made from a rough casting of plaster of Paris to which she applies a craft knife to reduce the resultant blob to something that looks distinctive to the species. Neither she, nor I, would think that these are photo-realistic 3-D models of living models but That's not the purpose. Like Viv O'Kelly and his Andalusian market-women, the search is for the essential by literally paring away the superfluous.

There's no point in doing this unless the results are different for different sorts of bird but I'm not saying that you need to know the Latin Linnaean names. That's how we, in science, communicate at a distance unambiguously what we are talking about. But knowing a bird is more than knowing its name: its call, its colour, its habitat, its flight, its appearance, its breeding strategy are all vital signs for its way of life. The LBJs [little brown jobs] are indistinguishable to ordinary folk, including me, because we don't devote enough focused-attention time to note the song, or the dark eyebrow or the orange legs.

I was skeptical early on with " . . . he remarks that there are fish who swim against the current - salmon and herring - who live in the open sea but are compelled to travel back to their rivers and streams to spawn" WTF!? Anadromous herring would be a first on this planet: although everyone knows that salmon do indeed hatch in fresh water and spend their adult life at sea. But that's reported speech; albeit uncritically accepted and not about birds, carving, painting or creative writing. [erratum: The Blob is just being ignorant about the natural world here: alewife and shad are indeed anadromous herring if you're broad in your use of "herring"]
In the end, the publisher has allowed a dozen bird sculptures to ornament the text; forming a thread that tethers the narrative to a finite part of the natural world and the written word:
handiwork by Sara Baume Birds Illustrated
Page English Linnaean Irish
7 Northern wheatear Oenanthe oenanthe Clochrán
13 Pigeon Columba livia Colm aille
25 Sparrowhawk Accipiter nisus Spioróg
37 Willow warbler Phylloscopus trochilus Ceolaire Sailí
49 Albatross Thalassarche melanophris Albatras dú-mhalach
63 Eastern phoebe Sayornis phoebe Phoebe an Oirthir
77 Swallow Hirundo rustica Fáinleog
101 Hooden crow Corvus cornix Caróg liath
117 Chaffinch Fringilla coelebs Rí rua
133 Arctic tern Sterna paradisaea Geabhróg Artach
163 Chough Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax Cág cosdearg
179 Pied wagtail Motacilla alba Glasóg shráide
197 Blackcap Sylvia atricapilla Caipín dubh
217 American redstart Setophaga ruticilla Earrdheargán Meiriceánach

While we're in memoir-land; check out Emilie Pine's Notes to Self or Kathleen Jamie's Sightlines - which is also heavy on birds. On blanking the confounding noise to reveal the essential signal, I've mentioned Matisse - Viv "Al Andalus" O'Kelly - Edvard Munch - Saccharomyces.
.

Friday, 10 July 2020

Vexillological numerology

Who let the Daft Quants out? 
On The Blob you can have any colour you want so long as it's black between #000000; and #FFFFFF; in hexadecimal RGB-speak. I've been tricking about with colouring words/letters since ever but a couple of weeks ago I started to put down some formal rules of engagement for colour formatting. Afterwards, I was fossicking around in the Irish political party space because we've just got a new government coalition, and suddenly up popped Categories: Irish Political Party Colours. There, some(obsessive)body has nailed single colours to the masts of all 93 political parties since the foundation of The [Free] State. This listicle naturally includes [s♩♫g ♩t] 40 shades of green but has a nicely variable palette, from NPD pink to Farmer's dung, for bar-graphs and pie-charts come election time.

A list of colours is data, and with data you can pose questions, form hypotheses, and then test them . . . you can do science. As these colours are what the party faithful choose to represent their values and their history, it might be worth asking whether political parties with similar values had similar colours or which was the most patriotic party - if you can define your terms for a) patriotic and b) distance / similarity.

Distance first. At The Institute, I've been supervising final year research projects in molecular evolution and bioinformatics although the students haven't really any prior knowledge of the key concepts; nor have they learned any programming languages. But they can make a certain amount of progress with Excel if the evolutionary question is framed so that something interesting can be derived with quite simple mathematics. A couple of my students have been tasked to discover if particular amino acids are buried in the proteins of which they form a part, or if they are exposed on the surface . . . and so available as a drug target. The key Excel task for this endeavour is to calculate the distance between two amino acids in 3-dimensional space if their X-Y-Z co-ordinates are known. For a great many proteins, their X-Y-Z coordinates are known [example shown R: units are Angstroms - real small], and recorded in PDB the Protein DataBase, because someone has calculated the 3-D structure of the protein using X-ray crystallography or Nuclear Magnetic Resonance NMR.

Euclidean distance can be calculated from the rules for Pythagorean triangles: if 32 + 42 = 52 then the distance between the two points = 5 = ✓( 32 + 42). The same principle applies if you're dealing with 3-D space or flat X vs Y planes. I decided to treat RGB colour space as orthogonal axes like the X Y Z coordinates of 3-D protein space.
  • HTML represents colours with 3 (Red Green Blue) hexadecimal digit-pairs from the range
    "0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 A B C D E F". 
  • FF is 16 x 16 = 255 in decimal [in nerdland you start counting from 0 rather than 1].
  • Pure white is #000000; and black is #FFFFFF; 
  • Other colours; #FF0000; #00FF00; #0000FF;  #FFFF00;
  • Distance: = ✓((R1 - R2)2 +(G1 - G2)2 + (B1 - B2)2)
Criteria for Patriotism. You can surely not do better for an exemplar of patriot green than with reference to the official green that appears on the Tricolour which is not the same as full on lime #00FF00 green nor yet kelly #4CBB17 green but rather a green with quite a lot of blue[shirt]: #009A49. But the Founding Fathers [and Constance!] went to considerable pains to include The Others in the North. How else could they aspire to a 32 county country after all? So Orange is included in the Republic's flag. 32 county patriots would clearly aspire to include the lads from the North. One way to achieve this in a single party colour is [see calcs R] to take the average values for Green White and Orange to give a sort of olive-drab hide--in-the-bushes #555B18 sort of a colour. And the results?
In the chart above, the column headed D is the green-only distance: how close party colours match the Tricolour Green. Winners Clann Éireann (founded Jan 1926: splitters merged with FF August 1927) and Socialist Republican Party (1944-1949) which adopted the same most patriotic colour but clearly flew too close to the fire of ardent republicanism and burned up in flames. Tied next in line are Irish Independence Party (1977-1985) and Sinn Féin which is still going strong.

The D32 inclusive-of-orange prize is won by the Éirígí [splintered from Sinn Féin 2006: no current elected reps] with Aontú [= Peadar Tóibín TD for Westmeath] as runner-up.

Exec Summ: Patriot Games 1st: Sinn Féin 2nd: Fianna Fáil 3rd Greens 4th Fine Gael 5th SocDems

Thursday, 9 July 2020

Mastering Science

Late in my working life, I started a full-time, full-on, job at The Institute. Late in my time at The Institute, I started supervising /mentoring research theses for the MSc in Pharmaceutical Regulatory Affairs. The students are a normal distribution, some earnest, some clever, some both, some neither. Some of them are still in touch and some have gone back to their own lives with whatever they got from the degree.

You be sure that only a tiny fraction of whatever they got from the degree ever appeared on the Syllabus or Learning Outcomes. Almost all the stuff you try to cram into your head to pass the final exams pops out over the next week because of elastic rebound. You never really wanted to store that information and it gets displaced by the next hot girl's telephone number; the location of the car-keys; or how to spell paraphernalia depending on your age and priorities.

When the thesis was finally submitted one of my recent mentees heaved sigh and wrote "Hope I’ll get the good mark for my work"

Which was a bit of a trigger for me, because the thing I hate most about teaching is giving marks out of 100. It seems absurd to reduce the tangled weft of the journey to a single number. Let alone a 68%.  Some of my colleagues are super confident at the reproducibility of their assessments: giving 6.8/10 for a lab report presumably in the belief that it's neither 6.7 nor 6.9/10. The somewhat pompous gist of my reply was: Marks are someone else's opinion of your work and they are relevant. But for me the most important thing is for you to recognise that you've done something original and creative, that you have worked hard and revealed something interesting that nobody really nailed down before. When we started this journey 8 months ago, you knew no statistics and had never scraped data from a PharmRegs website. There are only 6 people in Co Carlow tonight who know or care what a Yates Correction is - it's a very select club. By Christmas you will have forgotten about Chi.Sq. (and Yates Corrections) and you may never need to use that test again, but I hope there will always be a warm glow from having learned something new, that seemed difficult, and that you mastered it.
That's why it's called Master of Science.

Wednesday, 8 July 2020

An honourable profession

Katherine Rundell is a Fifty Pound Fellow [for Eng Lit] at All Souls' College, Oxford. She also writes children's books. At the end of last year, Bloomsbury published another book by her Why you should read children's books, even though you are so old and wise. Well, she would say that, wouldn't she? And although it's bound as a book, looks like a book, it more of a pamphlet at ~6,000 words. But none the worse for that and I'm glad this memoir is out there and indeed glad that one copy is in my left hand now.  It was one of two books which were hand-carried, by a circuitous route, to me from Dau.I the Librarian for my birthday last month. Because of its length you can read it through in a sitting; and travel from a dusty public library in Harare, Zimbabwe to the second star to the right, and straight on 'til morning.  Which as any reader of children's books will know, and love, are Peter Pan's directions to Neverland.

I've mentioned Francis Spufford The Child That Books Built before: his memoir is about learning to read [he started with The Hobbit and it was dead slow for the first many pages] and then becoming a bookie-monster devouring everything that had pages and was within arm's reach. Rundell also mentions him and his book with approval. And she also quotes Martin Amis with less appro "People ask me if I ever thought of writing a children's book. I say, If I had a serious brain injury I might well write a children's book". Which is just the sort of magisterial dismissal you'd expect from a self-regarding pretentious git like Martin Amis.

I was a late reader, but spent my teenage years ploughing through a school library which was heavy on  Penguin Classics  and light on froth. Although I read that too when I could find it. Heck, like Somerset Maugham, I read telephone directories, although that was a bit later. There is little to be gained from reading Ulysses at the age of 16; or Augustine's City of God. Because some life experience is necessary to find any ding-dong resonance there. But I was really glad that I found Mervyn Peake's fantasy Gormenghast and held that close to my heart while everyone else was doing Lord of the Rings. LOTR was the Harry Potter of my day and I read it through, twice, but I'm sorry I was too early to get off on the films instead: because there are chunks where Tolkien disappears through his own ring into tedious obscurity. Do we need Tom Bombadill? We do not.

As an Eng Lit academic  - an expert on John Donne, no less - Rundell's book is leavened with wit and literary references "As a child, I had no illusions that children were sweet: children, I knew from my furious heart, were frequently nasty, brutish and short". But she admits to cutting her readers some slack on the vocabulary side: facade, abundance and renunciation make it to the page but adamantine ends up on the cutting room floor. It's like me using the word "salient" in lectures at The Institute on the assumption that my read-nothing students had built up the same vocabulary as my over-educated self. Cutting young readers some slack is not synonymous for dumbing it down to reading age 9. It means thinking a bit about word-choice and not creating an impenetrable clever-me long-word blizzard. Children are quite able to process-or-skip new words as they are encountered. Between the age of 2 and the age of 12, humans acquire a vocabulary of at least 15,000 words. That's a rate of about 5-a-day. If you only read them, you blow the sound of some words. Like the same Dau.I indignantly denouncing her sister for fengeing [feign] sleep in the back of the car.

Should you read children's books? Absolutely, with or without pictures.