Thursday, 2 July 2020

Saiga debrinked

Q. Want some good news?
A. Aye, surely!
The Saiga antelope Saiga tatarica is a Eurasian artiodactyl closely related to the Springbok Antidorcas marsupialis of Southern Africa. They used to range over the whole continent from the Caucasus to China; indeed if you go back far enough Pleistocene fossils ave been found from North America to the Western European Archipelago WEA. The species have been under pressure from people a) who want to close borders which impacts on this long-range migratory grazer b) who want their horns for woowah medicine and are prepared to pay €5,000/kg for them. Census numbers were steadily edging down but fell off a cliff in the Spring of 2015 when haemorrhagic septicaemia raged through the population killing half of them [The Blob then]. Their genetic diversity is low because habitat destruction, pollution and rifles have forced the species through several genetic bottle-necks. If a pathogen rears its deadly head, then all the Saiga will go down because they all have the same, inadequate, immunological tool kit. In 2015 it was Pasteurella multocida and Clostridium perfringens, normally innocuous members of the normal bacterial flora, which went postal perhaps because of a really crappy weather system that blew through the steppes just before food started to pick up after the Winter but after the calves had been dropped. The grasslands were littered with corpses.

This season has seen a spectacular rebound in calving, with more than 500 neonates located and tagged in one region of Kazakhstan which is being comprehensively monitored by rangers.  That's compared to N = 58 in 2018 and N = 4! in 2019, so everyone involved is clicking heels for joy. Apparently you couldn;t hear yourself think for the bleating. Check out National Geographic where there's a 6 min micro-documentary on the recovery project. via IFLS


Wednesday, 1 July 2020

Manners maketh Mask

My old boss tweets as a scientist and human rights activist.  She has decided to put a poster on the door into her lab to welcome people when Lab Science re-opens for business in July.  I should note that she was extraordinarily ahead of the curve in March. Almost all of her senior colleagues convinced themselves that the war would be over by Christmas Easter and so shuttered their labs and tasked all their Effectives on <yawwwwn> literature reviews. The Gaffer otoh encouraged her people to up-skill themselves on multivariate statistics, Big Data analysis, bioinformatics and molecular evolution. I've been advising a little on an extraordinary study looking at the causes of infertility from a 60 million year perspective. It's a wonderful example of turning Coronarama from a threat into an opportunity: the "kids" would never have mastered those skills and developed a broader evolutionary perspective on their research niche if they'd been normally busy-busy flipping the eppendorfs and running gels in the lab. But I was a little weirded out by the background to the YOU ARE WELCOME HERE message . . .
  • I R confuse! Why is the serenity/ harmony stripe crossed out with white? And what's going on in the bottom left corner? Is that a + ?  Is it a white square to include/welcome The Patriarchy?
    • Well duh! I sent the picture and my questions to Dau.I my BLT Liaison Officer BLO. And she replied It's  the periodic table, stupid . . . didn't you read the original e-mail?? I'd been thinking it was all about Me-the-Patriarch and it's just colours roughly superimposed on the iconic "science" table [multibloboprevs]
  • The trouble with particularising whom you include is that someone will inevitably feel left out.
    • It's unthinkable that Trans-folk would have been singled out for inclusion 10 years ago. And women-in-science were, to the nearest whole percent, invisible even 60 years ago. It might therefore be worth thinking forward about our current invisible certainties to image what will look culpably careless for 20 years hindsight in 2040.
  • But the gesture poster is better than no statement. I've been sporting a rainbow wrist-band 24/7 since Sept 2018 hoping to offset some of the burden of my obvious Partiarchy for my marginalised students. 
    • It's good if everyone, including me and you, explicitly specifies {their | her | his} pronouns so that some people, for whom it's important, don't feel like a sore thumb; and continually have to explain who they really are.
  • And I've been an early [March] adopter of being masked out shopping because I don't care about looking like a dork/bandito and it might tip the balance of acceptability for whom it's important.
    • Talking to Dau.II at the end of last week, she confirmed that she had ordered a couple  masks but hadn't yet used one shopping . . . partly because she would look silly but also partly because in these heightened emotive times she might attract adverse comment (or assault??) from a particularly strident anti-masker. Because some people just love to tell other folk how they should behave in the process; forgetting that good manners is about making other people feel comfortable.
Hope helps, El Silverbacko
PS Check out Max Siedentopf for wonderful ironic masks. Much Maskilarity in Nairobi.

Tuesday, 30 June 2020

Setting an example

In my latter years working at The Institute, as deficits of age accumulated, I would start the year in each class by explaining that, if I cut them in the canteen, it wasn't because I was too grand to acknowledge their lowly existence but rather because my eyesight was too poor to recognise them as mine. And I hoped they would have enough empathy to appreciate that it would be kinda freaky if other students were being greeted effusively by a random silverback. That, and an explicit <shows rainbow wrist-band> affirmation that I was down with the gays. There was a subtext here that I wouldn't tolerate anyone getting slagged on my watch for: coming from Wexford; having facial hardware; being super shy; playing, or not playing, sports; let alone for having: a great tan, XX chromosomes, or any sort of BLT identity.

I also felt very strongly that it was okay if I didn't know all the answers. Indeed that it was a better educational experience because I didn't know everything: my ignorance put more pressure on the students to find out for themselves. But I surely wouldn't have had as much confidence in that theory when I was starting out as a graduate student teaching lab sections when I was only a few of years older that the average UG student in class. And if I was a young woman, or a young black woman, or trans, how much harder would it be to be wrong or to not know the answer?  That being said, it's also really important to convey a Joy of Science enthusiasm for the tasks to be covered; even if those tasks were intrinsically not-the-cutting-edge "discoveries" of, say, Hooke's [1676!] Law about strain, stress and springs.

That was all brought into focus for me by a nice little confessional essay in Science The pressure to assimilate about dress, comportment and being your true self by 'Trai Spikes [R about to get all wet in the field], a black student running ecology labs in Oklahoma U. Along the way growing up, he'd bought into Polonius' advice about apparel oft proclaims the man: that you get more respeck if you dress up. You'd better be stonking bri'nt if you turn up for a job interview in a tee-shirt and trainers; while an ironed shirt and pressed trousers will show who's in charge of the Biology 101 labs. But then young Trai was brought to realise that he was being viewed as a sell-out to The Man by his minority students. And he found that being his true self made him happier in his own skin and that allowed his passion for science to radiate around the room and inspire another generation of young scientists. Double Triple Win!

I have a nice little story about looking the part from when I was a post-doc in TCD in the early '90s of the last century. In the Genetics Department we had a weekly seminar series and a small budget to bring in visiting speakers. My boss, who had done his PhD in Edinburgh, decided to invite Howy Jacobs from Glasgow to do us the honour. Coincidentally the department had recently advertised for a New Professor of Genetics. It was a bit late in the century for punk, but Howy appeared with tartan trews and a mohican [still has] . . . which he'd dyed kelly green to mark his visit to Dublin. My Boss, as you do, took the visiting speaker to the Senior Common Room for lunch. As they sat around having coffee in the deep arm chairs afterwards, a couple of tweed-jacket-leather-elbows academics approached. One of them arched an eyebrow to indicate irony and said
"Ah Paul, is this one of the candidates for the Chair in Genetics? Won't you introduce us?"
"No, this is Howard Jacobs, the Lister Professor of Microbiology, at Glasgow, he doesn't need another chair"
<pffffffff> collapse of stout party!

Monday, 29 June 2020

Ceci n'est pas un crapaud

Proceratophrys boiei is not a leaf
Science is one way of making sense of the world. Wordsworth had a view on how a crowd, a host of daffodils impacted the human eye to delight the soul. Wordsworth's distillation has improved my awareness and appreciation of the wonders of the ordinary.  One of the making sense tasks of science is classification: it helps to find commonality among the different ways of making a living on this planet. I was reflecting recently on Dry Heath and the extent to which this biome exists outside of text-books. My tentative conclusion is that biomes are real conglomerations of interacting species which can help us predict what will be present in newly investigated landscapes. Any exceptions may be treasured because they will extend our understanding but the exceptional baby shouldn't require us to deny that the biome bathwater is wet.

Cycloramphus lithomimeticus is not a wet stone
Classification can be applied, not only to ecosystems, but also to the species of which they are comprised. In 1975 I concluded that it was not useful to base your classification on a single obvious attribute - we'll put all the flyers [bats, beetles, birds, butterflies] in this bin; all the sedentaries there; whales and sharks in that tank - not least because some birds swim better than they fly; and barnacles, birches and Bob-the-sofas make a very heterogenous group of sitters. Concentration on obvious features for diagnosis and classification has led us up the garden path a good few times and invisible DNA sequences have really helped to resolve who is related to whom.

Scythrophrys sawayae is not dried leaf-litter
Today, I am compelling you-eeeeuw! to look at the extraordinary lengths to which some frogs have gone to avoid being eaten. Unless you believe in a very diligent and slightly unhinged special creator for each of these solutions to the problem of predation, then the rest of us turn to the incremental changes wrought by evolution to explain both the differences and the similarities. You don't have to be a perfect mimic of a stick to survive long enough to get in a bonk or two and leave similar-looking offspring to posterity; you just need to look a little less froggy and more nothing to see here leafy than your neighbour. It's like you should always distress your bike a little and try to lock it near to a really swish expensive looking model belonging to someone else. Frogs need to keep still too, and be lucky, but looking a bit leafy may get their gametes over the line. For me the interesting thing is that these species are as different from each other as can be while still being mustered into Order Anura.
Cycloramphus lithomimeticus is in the family Cycloramphidae
Proceratophrys boiei is in the family Odontophrynidae
Scythrophrys sawayae is in the family Leptodactylidae
Odontophrynidae used to be lumped in with Leptodactylidae until 2006 DNA data suggested that they were a) a clade - a group of species descended from a common ancestor b)  longtime separated from the Leptos. Thus the evolutionary strategy of trying to look like something else has been re-invented multiple times . . . because it works.

Sunday, 28 June 2020

True voices

Lock down last week?
  • Latvian woodcraft-folk folk
  • Meanwhile on the streets of Dublin
    • Allie Sherlock and Cuan Durkin can't help falling in love
    • Cuan Durkin & Rosie Byrne do Perfect
    • Allie Sherlock and Cuan Durkin do Perfect
      • It's not technically perfect but they are all so full of heart. ya gotta love them. And could someone feed that boy up ? He's sooo thin and always cold.
  • Land of sand
    • Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh making a ham sandwich sets a very low bar: what a terrible bread to bracket sound locally sourced and home-cooked simple food. Any of his neighbours [okay I guess they'd have to be older than 60 and female] could knock up a round of brown soda and have it round to Mícheál's within the hour.
    • Meanwhile in Portugal they blame the French for this heart attack between two slices of bread . . . and slathered in gravy. Não é um milhões de passos do poutine.
    • My grannie's kilo-samosa business
    • Nutella in Reactistan
  • Scienciness
  • The Arts: park your prej its hard to see where the irony ends
  • History channel

Saturday, 27 June 2020

They all growed up

If you're new to The Blob, you may not even have met Dau.I and Dau.II (with whom I have half my genes in common) let alone twigged that they educated themselves at home and are now out and about in this dark world and wide [source]. They grew up with a cohort of youngsters who were similarly deprived of that school experience. None of them were struck in the back of the head with a spit-ball; none of them had their head flushed down the t'ilet in the boy's jacks; none of them were told they couldn't play soccer with the bigger chaps; none of them had to ask permission to go for a pee; none of them were told they were crap at maths or that girls couldn't become doctors. Although, to be fair, The Beloved had go Socratic on our 6 and 8 y.o. daughters to demonstrate that doctors were not exclusively male: "Now then: Doctor Farrell, whom we saw last month, is she a man?".

Meeting other parents at the school gates is, for most normal people, the last gasp at extending your social network which, apart from family, is mainly comprised of people you winnowed out of the crowd in school and college. We became founder members of HEN [the Home Education Network] in 1998, and that became our equivalent of the school gate crowd. Not all the parents were equally lovable and some of the kids (I blame the parents) were frankly bat-shit but the shared experience of educating children at home (not to mention rice-cakes, Birkenstocks, and floaty skirts) made us friends for life. We didn't meet up every M-F day in term-time but the shared experience - washing 100 dinner plates together, that time the tent collapsed, the night Bob set off the fire-alarm - made tight bonds.

In their mid-teen years, Lulu the mother of my Dau.I and Dau.II's Bestie, decided that the whole cohort could do with having their horizons broadened. Accordingly she organised a schedule of events, and called it Transition Year, for about 18 consecutive months that took a dozen or more HENnies to Arboretum, Belfast, Cork, Dublin . . . and through Youghal. We would have done the Zoo as well but were offended that the lions were insufficiently vegetarian. I was the other adult in the room for several of these adventures, so got to know those youngsters quite well. Everyone different, every one good, like sourdough bread. Now they're all grown up, have gotten and used the vote, have steered, and got an old man off his sofa, a couple of key social justice referendums through to Tá,

Back in the day, when we'd all get together, you may be sure that one of these youngsters had done something entirely creditable or manifested some amazing triumph of their talents. It made our little chicks look paltry because all they'd managed in the previous month was make cupcakes and clean out the chicken shed. It wasn't that the other parents were boasting or boosting. It took me a while to turn this on its end: a) if you have a month or more between meets then you're not going to share the boring bits; they will be effectively invisible while the prize-winning or life-saving events will dominate the mind b) the other families were mostly crap at cup-cakes and were amazed that one so young could be so talented with a wooden spoon c) it's not a competition, it just seems that way sometimes. Celebrating the ordinary became the path to contentment.

Monica O'Connor, [prev] another of the Transition Year Mams, has made good a promise to herself to interview that generation of home-educated kids, including her own, and find out what they've done since leaving home. She's got her self a youtube channel and is giving the were-kids the space to tell their stories. Whatever we felt about their achievements as teenagers, the Kids Done Good as 20-somethings [Quiz-time: spot the half-genes-in-common pair]:
But the hell with "success", which is chimerical and ultimately empty; you could not meet a nicer group of people, they give me hope for the future. Akala says don't let no-one kill your imagination.

Friday, 26 June 2020

Bloody covid

A couple of weeks ago, my KK correspondent G sent me a story in The Jerusalem Post about ABO blood groups and differential response to Covid-19. I was in the midst of a Covid moratorium so didn't follow it up. I did pause to reflect on why G was scanning the Jerusalem Post: surely if you live in the SunnySouthEast everything you need to know can be met by perusing the Munster Express?

The JPost is referring to a study in NEJM which has taken a blood sample from ~1600 people in the Spanish and Italian epicentres of early Covid-19 meltdown. At some stage in every patient's treatment bloods were taken and while they were routine checking for creatinine, serum albumin and alkaline phosphatase they also had to check ABO blood groups in case anyone needed a transfusion. I've written about ABO blood groups before in the context of priority - paternity - geography - history - disease association.  But my [slightly delayed] response was ooooo data and I scooted off to the NEJM to download Supplementary Appendix 8 which contains the raw counts and %s for ABO in various geographic and medical-severity bins.

The first thing to note is that Spain and Italy are not the same population wrt ABO blood groups and so, strictly speaking, the data from the two agglomerations should not be pooled. This fact was brought up to the top of my 'mind' because one of the tables in Appendix 8 has gathered a bunch of Basque ABO data as a control. Whoa, lads! The Basques are the Martians of Europe, even more so than the Magyars: their language is not proto-Indo-European PIE and their blood groups look like a sore thumb (mostly Rhesus diffs it must be said). As a side-swipe, note the different colours on the map [R] for Lombardy and NE Spain where most of the Covid-sick in the study came from.

I scraped the pooled ABO / Covid-serious cases / Disease free controls from Appendix 8:
Which tells us a) that there are a lot of data here b) that the number of hospitalised cases is about equal in the two countries (although quite uneven in among the several participating hospitals) c) that sick people include more GpA people and fewer GpO people than you'd expect if they were a random selection of the population based on the controls. Because the paper didn't do this, I checked for ABO heterogeneity between total ES controls and total IT controls with a simple Chi.Sq test. The base-line differences are highly significant (Chi.Sq = 27; df 3; p < 0.001) with their being more A alleles in Spain and fewer B. Which is grand because we effectively have two different parallel experiments which both reveal the same skew: you are about 50% more likely to finish up on a ventilator if you are blood group A and a third less likely to do so if you are Group O. This is the odds ratio OR: [explained] (a/c)/(b/d)  = 1.54 for Italy (it's 1.31 for Spain) where
  • a = ++ number of ventilated As = 388
  • b = +- number of unsick As = 451
  • c = -+ number of ventilated (AB+B+O) = 43 + 91 + 313
  • d = -- number of unsick (AB+B+O) = 50 + 163 + 591
You can do similar calcs with O vs ~O / sick vs well. What are you / me / we meant to do with that information? My correspondent G was jubilant that she was Group O. I'm Group A but I'm not really concerned although the odds look stacked against us the (elite) A-team.  There are far more people with Group A who are uninfected, asymptomatic or who have copped a dose and had mild to moderate symptoms because that's the ~80% in the Covid-19 world. The 20% who get real sick and the 1% who die (or have such a crappy experience that death is wished for) are disproportionately A, yes, but they are far more obese, diabetic, have cardio-vascular issues or are over 80 years old. I am none of those.  Ed Cara at Gizmodo has covered the story with extra input from front-liners “It’s a big headline, but scientifically, if one of my colleagues in the emergency room were to call me up and say, ‘Hey, we were about to intubate somebody, but then we noticed their blood group was O. Should we still do it?’ I’d be like, ‘You’re crazy. You’re just absolutely crazy,’” Gehrie said.

And remember that it takes two to tango: before you get a chance of a go on a ventilator, you have to first catch SARS-CoVi2. Me? I rarely go shopping; I wear a mask in LIDL; I wash my hands afterwards; I don't suck face with young wans in discos; etc etc. I don't think G should take fewer risks than me because her red blood cells each carry a really small titanium Captain America shield.

It's a bit like my analysis is Statins. They have demonstrable, statistically significant effect on lowering cholesterol and so will prevent heart attacks. But the number needed to treat NNT for statins is more than 100! 100 people have to be taking statins for 1 to not have a coronary infarction. Statins have wild side-effects in some people and will cost you (or the beneficent HSE) a chunk of money. You'd be better off changing your diet, getting off your couch, de-stressing and being more socially engaged. But these take effort, statins just need a small glass of water.
On Covid-19, you can't change your blood group but you'd be spiffin' bonkers to think
I R O, I R OK, I can share spittle with randomers