Thursday, 7 November 2019

Mileage

Useless if delayed! A month ago, I voluntered to bang the recruitment drum at a school-leavers job fair. Actually make that The Job Fair. Dozens of 3rd level educational institutions from Ireland and abroad have a presence there because thousands of school leavers will be in the same hanger for a couple of hours. Handing out brochures has got to be the most ineffectual method of persuasion but I could be convinced that an engaged chat with someone who works at St Trinian's College Dublin would tilt the table in StT's favour. You won't find anyone more bat-shit bonkers with enthusiasm than Old Bob. But I had a class to teach at 0900hrs on The Day. If I went by public transport, the whole event would be in the sweeping-up-unread-brochures phase. Accordingly, with the approval of my line manager and her line manager, I ran from class and arrived at the Fair (or affray) just after 1100hrs.

I talked until I was hoarse for the next three hours.

4 weeks later, our Admin told me that The Institute didn't approved of car-travel to Dublin - which is served by an efficient system of public bus and rail connexions. I knew that because, a few years ago, I loaded up my car with post-grads and we all drove to a {relevant | important | interesting} scientific conference. Then also, I got the travel signed off by my HoDept and the HoFaculty, but the application was refused by The Money because that was institutional policy. One could have wished that my managers had been aware of the policy when they signed the paper! Then we could have gone, at much higher expense and inconvenience, by public transport. I left the refused application form in my To Do drawer until the heat of indignation drained away.

That's the baggage. This year, Admin advised me to xerox an AARoadwatch route-planner and attach that with a brief explanation for Finance. Yer 'tis
My Yaris clocks the base-line [engine < 1200cc] mileage allowance €0.38/km so my application for refund was €64. Fatter cars, because less efficient at transporting fatter bottoms, can claim more 1200-1500 @ 40c and >1500cc @ 45c. The public transport cost (train taxi taxi train) is about €60 and, because it falls within policy guidelines, goes through the system like butter. We'll see if I get refunded . . . or if I have to go and spitefully shoot the three probable students I recruited at the HORDS event.

But really wot are we like with the mileage? At the last save-the-planet event I attended, the founder of one of the NGOs said that their policy for reimbursing travel for voluntees, trustees & committees is totally flat. Everyone gets the same mileage whether they come in a 4x4 Chelsea tractor, a  Yaris or a bike. That's got to be better. Why should the company subsidise your Choice to tool about the planet in a gas-guzzling steel tank?

There's an old joke about a magnate explaining his success to his over-privileged son.
Mag: When I were in t'school, lad, my folks used to give me the bus-fare but I'd run along behind the bus and save t'brass.
Son: But Daddy, why didn't you run to school behind a taxi and save more money?

Wednesday, 6 November 2019

Smartie well water

SMARTIE [logo R] might lay claim to Ireland's most contrived acronym (Spatiotemporal multiscale Modelling of Antimicrobial Resistance in the Irish subsurface Environment). It is a project funded by co-funded by the Irish Centre for Research in Applied Geosciences (iCRAG) [never 'eard of it although I know several on the payroll] and the Geological Survey of Ireland (GSI) [which has been around for 175 years, so I have heard of that institution].  A couple of months ago, a colleague at work fowarded a flyer from the Smartie Project which offered to test my bore-hole and domestic plumbing for coliforms, pH, and some other impactors on drinking water quality. What could possibly go wrong? Always short of Blob-copy, it seemed a bit of an adventure and so Reader, I signed up. It was a bit cheeky that The Blurb for Smartie explained how for two separate site-visit water-tests "total service valued at over €300. It is important to note that the EPA recommends testing your well water at least twice a year". Without well-owners' participation there would be no Smartie, we don't need to be thrEPAtened'.

Two months after I submitted my application I found that we'd been selected! Smartie needed a) an adult present to b) give access to the well-head to test the depth of the water-table c) indicate the location of an outdoor tap to sample the water. When we sunk the bore-hole, our neighbours Doran of the Well got the contract. As tree-huggers, we asked if he was going to dowse the ley-lines to find the best place to try for water. He raised a quizzical eye-brow "There's no shortage of water in Ireland, where are you going to install the pump and pressure cylinder? . . . then let's set up the rig as close to that shed as we can - save on pipework".

And it was so. We struck water at about 5m, but the flow was deemed insufficient, so they went on down to 35m or 113ft in old money. The price in old money was £4/ft. The drilling went on for several hours; sometimes the drill shaft was motoring steadily downwards but then it would pause and seem to make no progress. Once the super-hard blue granite seam had been penetrated progress downwards went on apace. It was the most entertaining afternoon: much more interesting than TV. That was 23 years ago, Dau.II was in diapers.

This is now. Between the anouncement of selection by Smartie and Sunday's visit I had to find the well-head which I hadn't seen since the man-hole cover was put down in August 1996. It wasn't hard because I was there when the well was sunk but I had to tonk about with an iron bar until the ground sounded hollow. Then I had to shovel off at least 50kg of dirt and gravel . . . until taDAAAH! thar she blows [L, note shovel leaning u against  the door of the "water-shed]. When Smartie, and her co-pilot / navigator / assistant arrived, we had a) the cover off b) the kettle on. I was delighted to get this boot-up-the-bum to have a look at the well rather than assuming that it wasn't full of dead rats and/or taking water from the surface of the yard. It was also interesting to note that the water surface was only 1.2m below grade, that the septic tank was 35m away and the drain-field another 10m beyond that. The water is pH5.6 which explains why the copper pipes have all been eaten away and replaced by qualpex plastic. pH5.6 is about 25x more acidic than water - pH is measured on a logarithmic scale. In any case, Smartie has taken away several samples of water and will plate the water out on McConkey Agar to see if any coliforms or Pseudomonas are present. If she can get any such 'wild' colonies to grow, she will then see how susceptible / resistant they are to a variety of antibiotics. All good stuff. I hope her well-water data is less noisy than that of my old student, now Dr Lithium.

Tuesday, 5 November 2019

Humpty Dumpty Fulmar

Q. What shall we call it?
A. fúlmár = “stinking mew” - náti = “foul” - havhestur = “horse of the sea”
!depending on location and context!
Name of something or someone is more than a label; it is, or becomes, freighted with meaning. A couple I know, occasional blob-readers were so cognisant of this power that they were tongue-tied for months in the matter of the naming of their first born. They eventually saddled the chap with Aimheirghin after the Milesian bard, he of the white knees Glúingel. Bard /druid / judge was a hard act to follow and . . . the very divil to write on the front of every copy-book in national school. But Aaron wouldn't be the same thing at all except as to sound.

I've pondered these issues before but was triggered by a longish essay by Simone Kotva about naming birds in Faeroese. Although Latin is excellent for communicating with The World - where Fulmarus glacialis is agreed by everybody to represent a particular species of sea-bird, it tells us very little about how the bird behaves, where to find it or what part it plays in the ecosystem or economy. That's not always true: Drosophila melanogaster (the black-bellied dew-lover) tells us something about its way of life; although the English common name fruit-fly also informs. Dick Feynman's dad famously sounded off about the irrelevance of the name to emphasise the importance of paying attention to the world around you: “You can know the name of a bird in all the languages of the world, but when you're finished, you'll know absolutely nothing whatever about the bird... So let's look at the bird and see what it's doing -- that's what counts.” [blobefore with vid-link].

Kotva gets close to the touchy subject of the eskimos have 40 words for snow [blobboprev] in a paragraph about puffins "puffin is known by the handbook as lundi, the closest to a general name for the adult bird. Historically, however, lundi refers primarily to the bird when cooked and stuffed with cake batter. A migratory puffin, by contrast, was called klædseksdrongur, or “luggage boy” (because it announced the arrival of the larger arctic skua) and a puffin in winter plumage was a høganevið, while a young bird was a vangagrái and a young bird “fallen on the field or into a river” was an áarpisa—finally, an old non-breeding puffin was known as karkarakkur, on account of its long, curved outside claws, a danger to fowlers".  We do this a little in common talk: cow, bull, bullock, heifer, calf, freemartin, ox; (not to mention Hereford, Angus, Dexter, Friesan) all refer to Bos taurus but each word represents only a subset of the species. I get the sense that the naming of parts in medieval and early modern deer-hunting and falconry was far more detailed, fussy and nuanced than those endeavours are today. If you've never eaten venison let alone gralloched a hind you really don't need to know all that.

Like the world's minority languages, which are dying at the rate of one every fortnight, we should be grateful that someone is taking the trouble to listen and record what a retired Faeroese fisherman calls the various birds which he has been observing since he was a nipper. It is more important to listen to the oldest inhabitant in oral rather than literate societies. Celebrate diversity now, they're not making any more of the stuff. One of the small-small things that inspired me to become a biologist was An Englishman's Flora with its evocative lists of names of common or hedgerow plants. In Ireland rural children have an impoverished vocabulary to work with because they no long work or play in the environment which surrounds their homes. Mammy drives them to school and they find Xbox more rewarding than feeding the hens or picking fraocháns.

I was delighted when Kotva used the word kenning in the context of Faeroese ornithological naming. Because, as I wrote about kennings at the very birth of The Blob,  a kenning is a phrase used widely in Norse, Anglo-Saxon and Greek narrative verse which conventionally and metaphorically names persons and things. For Homer the sea is usually οίνοπα wine-dark; Beowulf will travel the hron rad [whale-road] on his byrviggs [wind-horse] to bury his it dýra reyr dylgju [the precious reed of enmity] or hjálms fyllr helmet-filler in Grendel's head. Heck, I can taste the salt on my lips and I'll need conditioner when I next wash my hair.

The original Sealanguage essay flagged for me on Metafilter where one plaintiff commentator drew attention to the pernicious use of names and labels in the LGBT world. Last year in a Blob about pronouns, I touched on the daily horrors experienced by people who are othered by straight white patriarchs. As the patriarchy is quite a small and self-select group, The Others make up by far the majority of people on the planet.

Monday, 4 November 2019

Word loss

The Central Statistics Office An Príomh-Oifige Staidrimh is not just the overseer and processor of the decennial Census. They gather information about all aspects of life in the Republic and eventually get them into a form that can be interpreted by the government, other decision makers, movers and shakers as well as bloggers and constructors of pub-quizzes. Without reliable information, planners are at nothing, money will be wasted and we'll have a poorer, less equal society as a result. The CSO has an interest in encouraging numeracy, data gathering and crap-detecting in young people. Without embryonic quants coming through the school system, the office will have to employ numbskulls. The Visual Display of Quantitative Information [title of iconic book by Edward Tufte] is a vital skill that needs to be nurtured and encouraged: dense spread-sheets of data lack the power to persuade.

For the last several years the CSO has sponsored the John Hooper Medal for Statistics; and the 2019 results were posted in mid October. Next year's competition has been launched with a submission date in March. The deliverable is a Poster [PDF or PPT] and individuals need not apply because the learning outcomes include: "work as a team; investigate real questions using data;  use their analytical and graphical skills; interpret statistical results; develop skills in written communication". It is clear that these skills / attributes are what the CSO hopes to hire later.  I'm not going to make a judgement about quality but the range of topics is wide although somewhat limited by the limited experience of the competitors: teenagers are interested in txtn, transition year, social media, sports but some are also into the environment and politics.

The winners of the Irish medal Aisling Barry and Katrin Birk from Bandon Grammar School, Co. Cork  also won the senior category in the International Statistical Literacy Project (ISLP) poster competition, with their entry titled “A Statistical Analysis of the Accuracy of 5-day Forecasts in Predicting Hot vs Cold Temperatures” that Global competition was run by the International Association of Statistical Education (IASE) in KL, Malaysia. Barry and Birk used a Python script to scrape predicted and actual data from the Web for seven really random locations: Astana, Buenos Aires, Houston, Kinshasa, Roma, Sahr, Winnipeg. Prize to you for being able to locate these cities on a map of the world [accurate within 200km will do!].

Another couple of quants, Kate Bagnall and Bobbi Beattie from The King’s Hospital, Dublin. who won an honourable mention in the John Hooper event were young enough to be shipped out to KL for the born since 2003 category. Where they won! with “Using statistics to investigate changing use of language in Irish Primary students’ writing after 80 years”.  They also used a Python script to count word-usage among national-school children in the 1930s and now. Kids nowadays don't know nothin' about churning, warts or wells (they're all about wellness instead):
In 2015 the Oxford Children's Dictionary controversially removed a number of 'nature' words from the most recent edition to make room for current knowledge and usage. Bagnall and Beattie matched these lost words against those actually used by kids in the 1930s and came up with a long list.
Plants: vine, oats, buttercup, gooseberry, ash, ivy, bran.
Animals: magpie, lark, doe, ox, ass [bray], thrush, monarch, blacksmith.
Religion: parish, saint, sin, elf. 
But even modern children are using words, although fewer  in number than 80 years ago, that the authorities have deemed to be irrelevant.

Sunday, 3 November 2019

Tween Hallowe'en & Guy Fawkes

Two nights 31/10 and 05/11 when fireworks go off. Now for the calm between the pyrotechs.

Saturday, 2 November 2019

Recycle my arse

. . . and my arms, aorta, amygdala, adrenals, adenoids, arteries and appendix [YMMV on the appendix] and the B C D . . .  X Y zygaphophyses, zygomatic arch, zonula of Zinni. The whole darn shootin' match converted into potting soil. What's not to like about that?

Standard practice in Ireland is still burial; in a chipboard coffin with a veneer of "oak" and hollow brass handles, just strong enough for the ten minutes of heft that will carry the corpse from hearse to church to earth. Even that last lift of respect by the family is being replaced by a little fold-up trolley. When my father died in England, and I suggested that we might carry the coffin into church, the undertaker had a [demure, respectful] fit. Coffin-carrying is so alien to English tradition that nobody gets any practice. All the undertaker could see was that time the coffin was [almost] dropped.

Cremation is just beginning to make inroads in the corpse disposal market, as it becomes unacceptable on account of the carbon footprint: 250kg of C02 to dispose of a 70kg average person. Five years ago, The Blob looked at resomation the chemical option of deconstruction by concentrated sodium hydroxide / lye / caustic soda. It takes the same time as cremation and leaves a coliform-free greenish liquid that can be sprinkled on the fields - maybe after adjusting the pH to nearly neutral, hmmm?

Let's get back to the soil. You can make nitrogenous fertiliser by chemical means by applying heat and pressure to the nitrogen in the air and creating ammonia. Although atmospheric nitrogen is effectively unlimited and freely available - the Haber-Bosch process to make ammonia is really expensive in energy carbon units. Amazingly whole classes of bacteria including Rhizobium spp. are able to 'fix' atmospheric nitrogen by using enzymes - at normal temperature and pressure. Very fuel-efficient but it takes while.

Katrina Spade is digging deep to make apply similar principles to body degradation [BBC]: make the microbes do the work. You can do this if you add (ingredient list for cooks)
  • prebiotics - seemingly that is in large measure wood chips
  • a little heat - to bring the recompose ™ pod up to 55°C to 
    • kill the coliforms and pathogens
    • encourage thermophilic anaerobic bacteria
    • heat requirement is reported as being 1/8th that required for cremation.
  • time - about 30 days rather than 3 hours for cremation
I dunno, my experience is that the lactic acid bacteria in grass clippings will get a compost pile up to 55°C in a couple of days. Maybe some dicking about with the compost recipe will allow the microbes to do the heavy lifting on temperature as well as digesting all that fat and bone. Recompose seems to be a good compromise between time and energy input. It's going to be priced accordingly at about $5,000 compared to trad coffin burial at $7,000 and cremation nearer to $1,000. The facility [imagined R] has to be convenient to urban centres where land is expensive and the fermentation cells need to be properly engineered for multiple uses as opposed to the one-time cheapo packaging of coffins.

Plenty of interest in the Recompose FAQs
  • What's the output?
    • About 1cu.m. of soil
  • Can I donate my corneas, kidneys first?
    • Of course!
  • What happens to the bones/teeth?
    • Whoof!: NH3 C02 H2O
  • What about my meds, last-ditch antibiotics?
    • decomposed entirely: they're not harder than teeth
  • What about my titanium hip?
    • screened out along with amalgam fillings, pacemakers, face hardware
  • Any exclusions?
    • not keen on prions like Creutzfeld-Jakob Disease [bloboPrev], or Ebola
  • Can I invest in your enterprise?
    • Ye$
https://www.lastthings.net/ for DIY help and advice [via MeFi]


Friday, 1 November 2019

Admissions of Henry Marsh

It's nearly 5 years since I read, and reviewed, Henry Marsh's [R prev, with links to interviews with, filmlets of and long-form articles by] last book Do No Harm. Marsh retired recently from working for the NHS as a brain surgeon; but I believe he still comes into theatre sometimes in London or Kathmandu. He's also on the lecture circuit, in the UK and abroad, talking to medical students about [over-]confidence, transparency, paper-work and trust. Do No Harm was an international best-seller, so there will have been pressure on the author to dig out another bookful of anecdotes, opinion and reflections. Admissions is the result, the clever title being due to Marsh's second wife, social anthropologist and author Kate Fox. Me, I'm more interested in the anecdote Admissions (the patients, their cases, their outcomes and the lessons to be learned) rather than the introspection Admissions (confessions to many of the deadly sins and nightmares of guilt about all those who have predecesaed the author]. Nevertheless, even the second eleven trawled from an interesting life is worth reading. As in his last book, Marsh is eminently readable so I motored through Admissions in a couple of evenings; you could do worse.

If you're a health administrator - and there are a heluva lot of them now - you might reflect on how policies designed to keep accountability and balance the books can undermine trust among the front-line staff. Under an NHS  diktat called the Duty of Candour, surgeons are compelled to apologise when mistakes were made, but it is hard to reconcile that compulsion with "for an apology to be meaningful it must be genuine". Maybe a new generation of surgeons, trained in candour and humility, will be more sincere in shouldering responsibility when things go wrong. But elsewhere, Marsh reflects on the positive benefits to patients and family when young doctors are confident and decisive even when their lack experience should tell them that they are still learning their trade the hard way.

In a long saga of a whiplash claim and counter-claim that brought Marsh to compo court and many lawlerly offices he thinks "The principal consequence of that trivial accident . . . was not just the plaintiff's pain and suffering, but also the Babylonian marble offices where we were now meeting".  Of course negligent doctors must be brought to book, to alert the system and stop that sort of thing recurring. But shit happens, even in the best run and most competent surgical theatres and it is ungood if more and more of the national health spend is converted into lawyer's Porches through spiralling insurance premiums. Quite apart from taking the Effectives away from work in hospital to attend endless hearings where suits are paid by the billable hour.

Neurosurgeons are well compensated, even when the cash is top sliced for insurance and tiers hospital administrators. Cash has allowed Marsh to indulge in an almost pathological acquistion of stuff. Late in life he taught himself to become a wood worker - complementary to handling far more wibbly-wobbly material in his day job. He has several chain saws, banks of chisels, boxes of clamps, handfuls of hammers, mallets and punches. His father used to collect antiques, when much of it was called "old junk" and could be picked up cheap. Marsh Jr. has gone for a redundancy of tools and a library of books which he will never read again. " It often seems to me that happiness and possessions are like vitamins and health. Severe lack of vitamins makes us ill, but extra vitamins do not make us healthier. . . possessions do not make us happier".  Amen, brother Henry!

If you're into end of life issues, you might catch Henry Marsh's review of  oncologist Azra Raza's The First Cell: And the Human Costs of Pursuing Cancer to the Last. It reflects on the fact that 75% of a white Westerner's life-time health spend is shovelled out of the inheritance pot in the last six months of poor quality life.