Friday, 1 November 2019
Admissions of Henry Marsh
If you're a health administrator - and there are a heluva lot of them now - you might reflect on how policies designed to keep accountability and balance the books can undermine trust among the front-line staff. Under an NHS diktat called the Duty of Candour, surgeons are compelled to apologise when mistakes were made, but it is hard to reconcile that compulsion with "for an apology to be meaningful it must be genuine". Maybe a new generation of surgeons, trained in candour and humility, will be more sincere in shouldering responsibility when things go wrong. But elsewhere, Marsh reflects on the positive benefits to patients and family when young doctors are confident and decisive even when their lack experience should tell them that they are still learning their trade the hard way.
In a long saga of a whiplash claim and counter-claim that brought Marsh to compo court and many lawlerly offices he thinks "The principal consequence of that trivial accident . . . was not just the plaintiff's pain and suffering, but also the Babylonian marble offices where we were now meeting". Of course negligent doctors must be brought to book, to alert the system and stop that sort of thing recurring. But shit happens, even in the best run and most competent surgical theatres and it is ungood if more and more of the national health spend is converted into lawyer's Porches through spiralling insurance premiums. Quite apart from taking the Effectives away from work in hospital to attend endless hearings where suits are paid by the billable hour.
Neurosurgeons are well compensated, even when the cash is top sliced for insurance and tiers hospital administrators. Cash has allowed Marsh to indulge in an almost pathological acquistion of stuff. Late in life he taught himself to become a wood worker - complementary to handling far more wibbly-wobbly material in his day job. He has several chain saws, banks of chisels, boxes of clamps, handfuls of hammers, mallets and punches. His father used to collect antiques, when much of it was called "old junk" and could be picked up cheap. Marsh Jr. has gone for a redundancy of tools and a library of books which he will never read again. " It often seems to me that happiness and possessions are like vitamins and health. Severe lack of vitamins makes us ill, but extra vitamins do not make us healthier. . . possessions do not make us happier". Amen, brother Henry!
If you're into end of life issues, you might catch Henry Marsh's review of oncologist Azra Raza's The First Cell: And the Human Costs of Pursuing Cancer to the Last. It reflects on the fact that 75% of a white Westerner's life-time health spend is shovelled out of the inheritance pot in the last six months of poor quality life.
Monday, 26 September 2022
The Prostate of Marsh
My mother put me on to Henry Marsh [multibloboprevs], the literary neurosurgeon, when she gave me Do No Harm: Stories of Life, Death and Brain Surgery nearly 10 years ago. Marsh is a little older than me and has lived through the transition from doctors being brusquely competent / confident [too often confused] to doctors being reined in by a stodgy sclerotic health service bureaucracy and the fear of litigation.
His latest and likely last book And Finally [2022] is available on Borrowbox audio read by himself. "Last" because he was diagnosed last year with late stage prostate cancer, was treated with hormones and radio therapy which got his PSA - prostate specific antigen - score down from 120 [!!] to 0.1 nanograms per milliliter (ng/mL). The 'normal range' is anything up to 4ng/mL and values higher that 10 will be a big red flag for your oncological urologist, or indeed your GP when your 'bloods' results come back. So Marsh is now officially in remission but having his PSA actively measured every six months. You might wonder at an actual brain surgeon being so stupid as to ignore the clear and present symptoms of problems down there for so long. But his reflections on denialism and his own feet of clay make for interesting and compassionate reading.And being brought up all standing with a potentially fatal diagnosis induces some reflections on the rest of his life. How he neglected his family in the pursuit of surgical ambition; how he was betrayed by his friend and mentee in Ukraine; how he was cheese-paring of empathy and compassion for his patients and their families. Reflections are matched with projections - not good because his PSA was so high that resurgence is likely. But even if he dodges that bullet, it is likely given his age, he will be carried off by something else. And in any case, for a fit and active person, the multiple organ deficits of the aging body provide the opposite of solace.
And that provides a launch-pad for promoting and making more widely available the option of assisted dying. His gripe is that, so far, the British political establishment has conflated euthanasia [we fought against the Nazis in the war], which excludes consent and assisted death which embraces consent. For Marsh assisted suicide is an older, more direct and altogether better phrase. It is, of course, possible to off yourself without involving any part of medical palliative professional universe but the 'easy' options are violent or messy or uncertain. The arguments against legislation for assisted suicide are not evidence based; and in many cases righteously officious and paternalistic and often involve other people suffering.
Meanwhile, in remission, Marsh's most regular gig is inventing bedtime zoom-stories for his three grand-daughters and continuing to work on a monster dolls' house of his own construction.
Monday, 19 January 2015
Primum non nocere
let God do the damage, than do it myself."
I got a late Xmas present from my mother Do No Harm: Stories of Life, Death and Brain Surgery by Henry Marsh, neurosurgeon. The title is derived from the Hippocratic Injunction primum non nocere [above all do no harm] which is not in the Hippocratic Oath and indeed seems to have been conjured up in the mid 19thC by Dr. Thomas Sydenham. The reason I have that header-quote is because it was advice or a musing given to Mr Marsh by his neurosurgical mentor. I've been ripping through it: the last book I finished Nate Silver's Signal and Noise took me 10 months. S&N was good stuff: chock-full of interesting and thought provoking material but I could put it down. It's interesting that DoNoHa has no illustrations: the writing is so lucid that you don't need a picture to save 1000 words. And this is not to say that the language is for reading-age=7; the horrendous tumours Marsh has dealt with are all properly labelled and acronymed and adequately described. I had to look up wikipedia, though, to find out why ITU is his preferred acronym but used interchangeably for Intensive Care Unit (answer: Treatment)
The neat little chapters each start with a medical war-story and use that as a springboard to further discursions on matters that engage the great man. Rather like the small but perfectly formed radio-essays by Alistair Cooke. Some of the themes:
- Compassion vs Detachment. Surgeons don't operate on their own family because their judgement is sure to be clouded by their anxiety to Do No Harm.
- In obtaining informed consent, you can tilt the discussion by saying that intervention may lead the patient to be disabled which guilts the family into believing/asserting that, of course, they will look after the damaged goods (forever!). That makes it emotionally easy for the medics and usually leads to them doing something OR you can ask "what would your boy want (for himself and for you)" which leads to a difficult and prolonged discussion to resolve the competing emotional needs of parents, siblings, wife, children and sometimes falls in with Hippocrates by doing nothing.
- You should never allow anecdotal thinking to cloud your judgement - just because you've been caught once by a vanishingly rare concurrence of circumstances and killed or 'wrecked' your patient does not make those circumstances more common or likely.
- After an explanation or a discussion, either brief or prolonged, nobody reads the multi-page informed consent form before they sign it.
- Moral hazard abounds in the National Health. If the patient or the relatives insist, an expensive and medically doubtful procedure may be carried out in order to prolong life for a few weeks or months. As no new surgery can be carried out unless a post-operative bed is known to be available, 93 year old Mrs Doohickey's biopsy may block the prerequisite emergency admission bed for, and so condemn, a young wage-earner with school-age children.
- Mistakes in surgery are usually mistaken decisions rather than slipping scalpels or operating on the wrong leg. In neurosurgery, the key is knowing when to leave well enough alone: going for the last tricky bit of adhering tumour is what rips the artery.
- You never get any experience if you do nothing.
- Young doctors do not get sufficient experience if they are compelled to work less than 48 hours in a week by a European Working Time Directive EWTD. Young Marsh worked 1 in 2 as a trainee doctor: on top of a working week he was on-call (sleeping in his clothes) every other night and every other weekend to be available for about 120/168 hours.
- Experience is built on mistakes [L view of Mr Marsh's St George's Hospital from where much of his experience is laid to rest].
- EWTD might result in more coherent decisions by doctors who are not woozy from sleep deprivation but it makes a monkey of continuous patient care: nobody really knows the base line status of patients in A&E or on the ward if they haven't been on the firing step for long enough to establish the base line.
- Ethics is hard
Monday, 26 January 2015
HomUncle Wilder
While Penfield had the lid off, he systematically stimulated the sides along a fold in the brain called the central sulcus [Top L across Penfield's head] and got the patient to call out where s/he felt the tingle (sensory) or which part twitched (motor). After many operations, where the responses among patients was accurately reproducible, he was able to produce a detailed map of the brain's view of the body. It was not quite as you might have expected. For example, your body is represented upside down with the head down by the ears and the toes poked down between the left and right hemispheres. The picture is symmetrical with the left hemisphere dealing with the right side of the body and the region devoted to the dominant hand is usually larger. The other finding that is less surprising with 20/20 hindsight is that certain small parts of the body loom disconcertingly huge on the homunculus that represents us in the brain. The lips, tongue and hands are much more important in terms of the number of neurons that support them than the shins or feet.
Anatomists sort of knew this before Penfield because you can do a neat experiment to work out the density of sensory receptors on various parts of the body. Get your guinea-pig to close her eyes and poke her with either one pin or two pins a known distance apart; ask her how many pricks she feels. Two pins can be centimeters apart on the shoulders and still be detected as one event while two pins 1mm apart on the lips or finger-tips can be readily distinguished.
Knowing this map clearly has implications for understanding the phenomena associated with phantom limbs. And while it is true that the penis is over-represented compared to the lower limbs it is dwarfed by the sensory importance of the hands. So, ladies, it is just not fair to say that men think with their penises: like you, blokes rely on their fingers. Wilder Penfield was born 26th Jan 1891 >!today!< in Spokane, WA and died in 1966 in Montreal, he was a pioneer of the then unknown landscape beneath the skull. Hats off . . . so he can make the first incision?!
Wednesday, 18 January 2017
Going going gone
The book the way we die now [harrrumph, another book title without capital letters] was written by Seamus O'Mahony, a consultant surgeon specialising in alcoholic liver disease, now working in Cork. He spent 15 years working for the NHS in Britain, and the book draws on his experience in both countries. I've written about hospital death before - Atul Gawande's Mortality for the US experience; Henry Marsh's Do No Harm: Stories of Life, Death and Brain Surgery. I have filled in an advanced health-care directive AHD ticking all the don't intervene boxes, although I haven't yet gone so far as to have No CPR tattooed on my chest. O'Mahony is skeptical about AHDs: "no surgical intervention" precludes a quick nip and tuck to prevent copious bleeding in the stomach which can be fatal; resolving the bleed is most unlikely to leave you in a persistent vegetative state or with broken ribs [as in CPR]. The problem with such documents is that they are largely driven by anecdotal reasoning: such a thing was visited upon my Aunt Gwendolyn, I don't want that to happen to me; which is then summarised in a short generic phrase on the ADH. The phrase sounds firm and clear but rides rough-shod over the wobbly old nuance of real life. It's never exactly the same situation. In particular, it is very different when you are the principal actor: whatever your level of empathy or intimacy, it is easier to switch someone else off than yourself.
the way we die now is not particularly long but it is discursive and doesn't give any hard answers or advice. Which is a pretty good metaphor for our engagement with death. As I say above every death is different and, if you believe every life is sacred, each end-of-life will have particular circumstances that don't always, or ever, fit neatly into a piece of legislation or a standard operating procedure SOP. Most deaths in Ireland, the US, the UK and much of the Western World happen in hospital and all civilised countries have rules are regs about terminating other people's lives. O'Mahony has a locus standi on the issue because he's been there many many times. It goes with the territory if you choose to work in an acute hospital. Inevitably his experience has coloured his practice and opinions; we know this because the book is filled with anonymised Endings to illustrate particular points. One of his key issues is 'informed consent' which we are now required to get from participants in medical trials [for, say, drug development] or medical interventions [surgery, chemotherapy, medications]. The doctor has to explain, in words the punter or the next-of-kin can understand, what are the potential down-sides of such a treatment, what are the benefits and what is the risk [likelihood x magnitude of gain/loss]. As most of these punters will have bought a Lotto ticket in the last month, they are clearly not equipped to do the math. This will not stop them having forthright opinions about what the doctor should do and that is usually to throw the book [MIMS] at their ailing relative; and insert tubes in all orifices to keep the Principal alive, preferably forever.
There is little room for palliative care in such a dynamic and there is, increasingly, the threat of the law. This is last thing the medical profession wants because it will impinge on their judgment and autonomy. We-the-patient, however, would like to have a bit of legislation because we remember the medical gaffes [eg symphysiotomy] for a long time. The law is a blunt instrument which is only peripherally related to justice or common sense. O'Mahony devotes time to the case of Janet Tracey who broke her neck after being diagnosed with terminal cancer. The hospital applied a DNR without her consent and lost their case in the British Courts. Similar cases now force medical staff to try anything and everything regardless of cost [not only financial cost] if 'the family' require it. It seems a bit odd to me: the desires of a particular group of next-of-kin with their own peculiar internal dynamics are now allowed to force an additional burden on me the tax-payer [an on the poor continuing to suffer patient]. All that money and time spent on 'hopeless' cases in acute wards or ICU could be spent on a new anti-smoking campaign, or a fitness regime for fat children . . . or the homeless or refugees if that's what engages you this Winter.
O'Mahony, in his chapter A Passion for Control, also has little patience with Marie Fleming who forced the state to engage with her through the court system up to an including the Supreme Court. She sought the Right to Die in a way that suited her rather than being forced to exit when her multiple sclerosis closed down her systems. The media, including The Blob, was generally approving of her bravery in taking a case that would clear the decks for others with terminal disease to exit in their own homes rather going on a final foreign holiday to the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland. O'Mahony investigates the particulars of Marie Fleming and concludes that she had control issues. Whatever the cost of a couple of weeks of medical intervention at the end of life, the costs of multiple increasingly expensive court appearance is astronomical [the state picked up the tab]. Senior Counsel feel they are even more entitled to money than medical consultants; and they don't need to put some aside for medical negligence insurance premiums.
Finally there is a whiff of trolleology about the arguments for medical intervention. Trolley ethics experiments show that most normal people would happily throw a switch to kill one person and save five lives but would be less willing to heave a fat chap over a bridge balustrade to achieve the same 5 vs 1 result. Medical ethics seems to be fine with allowing a patient to dribble out their existence with inattention but vehemently against cranking up the morphine on the syringe driver to clear the bed. I reckon the latter is kinder: we thought that when we terminated our beloved dog, but we are not allowed to think it about our mothers.
One final thought: there are 7.5 billion people on the planet. Some would argue that is about 5.5 billion too many. When there were far fewer people life was cheap, now paradoxically, it is super expensive.
Friday, 4 May 2018
When breath becomes air
Trained he eventually was, and bravely decided to specialise in brain surgery. A lot of good doctors flame out at that stage in their career and choose a specialty that is less stressful, more lucrative and has the chance of weekends off or seeing the kids for at least one end of the working day. Not Kalanithi, he worked for all the hours and damaged people that god sent him, and at the age of 36 was on the cusp of Arrival. Just a few more gruelling months in theatre and counselling his patients and he'd land his consultancy. Then, maybe, he'd be able to take his foot off the pedal or have a wider impact on his field than the next case. Then his wife, also a doctor, said she'd had enough on this treadmill and needed to take some self-time to consider her position and, essentially in the same week, he was diagnosed with inoperable metastatic lung-cancer.
"When Breath Becomes Air" is a reference to a short poem by Fulke Greville, a contemporary of Shakespeare,
Do we need another book On Death and Dying? Perhaps more than we need another cookbook: 20% of the current best-sellers in non-fiction are for foodies. Is this part of the obesity epidemic? Anyway, as I suggested in the first paragraph, this one reads very well and I didn't faint once, so the blood and sputum must be kept more or less under the bed-clothes. Part of the readability must stem from the fact that Kalanithi started adult life as an English major but he had a parallel life in science because he also got a BSc degree in Biology. No more than myself, who was heading for History Economics and Politics until an accident lurched me into science aged 16. I am fulfilling my literary pretensions writing daily for The Blob; Kalanithi only wrote the beginnings of his book after his terminal diagnosis and the manuscript was prepared for publication after his death. He was really too busy in the mill of doctoring to find/make time to write literature. The Forward, by another literary doctor, talks about the cadence in Kalanithi's writing. But I'm guessing that's what I call readability: the story rattles along because the reader isn't brought up all standing by an awkward phrasing or an unreferenced allusion. Maybe it would do well as a talking-book? Like "The well-dressed man is he whose clothes you never notice"
Another edge to the story is that, having been career driven medical professionals, Dr & Dr Kalanithi had put 'family' on hold until they'd reached another goal and another and another. If you think in those terms, it is always better to try for a child next year rather than this year. Having got his terminal diagnosis, before he went for his first DNA-changing medical intervention, they went along to a sperm bank to make a deposit. A short while later, they cashed in those wriggly chips and Dr. Lucy fell pregnant. The girl Cady [R with her Dad] was born 8 months before her father died. He was there for her arrival and she was very much there for his departure. I hope it all works out for the relicts.
I'm not sure this book worked for me. It has the virtue of being thin, so it doesn't take long to read. But you're still paying the standard whack for the book as, say A Natural History of the Hedgerow, but with only half the words on the page and only 60% of the page-count [I counted]. But there is something 'constructed' about the book, as if it has been crafted for the NYT best-seller list. No harm in that, it might help ensure the future finances of Lucy and Cady. There will be other stories about death-and-dying, and I've cited some above, maybe be they won't read so self-consciously like the book is the elephant on the wall overseeing and editing everything that happens.
YMMV! The authenicity of the voice is what matters. You can get a handle on that by watching Lucy Kalanithi talking about choices and values on TEDMED. There is no doubt that getting the most out of a best-seller involves a gruelling round of interviews, book-signings and talk-shows for the author. Here's Lucy being interviewed by Channel 4, much less 'noisy' than the equivalent material on US TV channels.
Where's the Science? They shout. I thought it Matters. Well here's a gedankenexperiment that appeared on the first page of my Physics school text-book. Your lungs and mine [a little less for the ladies] contain about 6 litres of gas. It is a chemical constant that any mole of gas at standard temperature and pressure fills a volume of 22.4 litres. A mole is a gram-molecular-weight and contains Avogadro's number of molecules: that would be a mind-meltingly large number = 6 x 10^23. So your lungs contain 1/4 of that number of (mainly nitrogen) molecules - call it 1.5 x 10^23. Because air is light, all those molecules = a lungful weigh about 4 grams! That's small, NASA calculates that the total mass of the atmosphere weighs in at 5 x 10^21 grams. So the ratios molecule:lung and lung:atmosphere are within two orders of magnitude. A bit of jiggling with your assumptions [perfect mixing, exhale volume is not total lung etc.] comes down the statement "every breath that you take [cue Sting], contains a single molecule from the dying breath of Julius Caesar . . . and Paul Kalanithi . . . and lot of termite fart - there are a helluva lot of termites.
Friday, 4 July 2025
Too long too easy
In the early 1970s, when I was getting to college, people were beginning to apply evolutionary theory to help understand the human condition. The basic idea was that, through comparative anthropology / primatology we could speculate about the social structures of early humans. It could then be suggested that some of the drivers of social relationships might be genetically hard-wired rather than learned anew each generation. This was controversial because biological determinism, if it was hard-wired, might make it impossible for the dispossessed to get a fair share of the cake. These ideas came to a head when EO Wilson [obit] published Sociobiology in 1975. An earlier exponent of the idea that 1 million years of evolution in anatomically modern humans might impinged on how soccer teams or boardrooms worked was Lionel Tiger and Robin Fox, The Imperial Animal (1971) [review]. You could hardly choose more eponysterical author names for a book about biological anthro.
Robin Fox has a daughter Kate Fox who works as an experimental sociologist in Oxford. She is married to author neurosurgeon Henry Marsh [whom prev], not that it makes any difference - she's a person in her own right, not a chattel of the men in her life. I got her chunky book Watching the English: the hidden rules of English behaviour. (2004, 2ndEd 2014), out of the library recently. It's 225,000 words [far too] long and not enough chips. There aren't many copies in the Irish library system and there was a reserve on the title, so I didn't read every word. There's a chapter on the relationship of English people to English television, for example. We last owned a telly 40 years ago (in England), so all that is a closed book to me and I skipped that chapter.Other sections made my skin crawl with shivers of recognition, so I didn't dwell on them either. What I did read is readable and amusing in a breezy sort of way. It is based on experimental work, so is not a series of anecdotes and opinions. The experiments are science but not as hard scientists might recognise it. I'm not getting snitty/sniffy here: I had my name on a number of papers in biomedical immunology which had small samples, large error bars and quite woolly conclusions. Those conclusions are quite likely irreproducible, if anyone could be bothered to replicate our underpowered experiments.
Our results were based on molecular biological assays where the reagents cost a lorra money and patients and controls were limited. €500,000 doesn't go far in Eppendorfia. Fox's research is cheap: like bumping into people in railway stations and counting the number of times they say sorry; or sitting in the pub eavesdropping on blokes slagging each other off as a surrogate for showing affection . . . and counting the insults. But it doesn't seem to be based on thousands of interactions. Maybe it doesn't need to be. Fox's theme or thesis is that the English are funny. Irony rules! Self-deprecating humour is a key ingredient in social lubrication in England. I do that, it's how I was brought up (in England). The English also tend to be punny which is an acquired taste and I'm glad I don't have to endure the careful arched-eyebrow delivery of clever word-play any more.
StopPress: Had a visit yest from a friend who lives in Newry and commutes daily to Dublin. In contrast to the English, they talk to each other on the train. Only among Team Carriage C, mind: wouldn't know anything about those Others from Carriage A. But Carriage C has a Christmas party and all the other elements of successful Third Spaces. Brits are missing something walled up behind their newspapers immersed in their devices not making eye-contact
Monday, 2 March 2015
Mortality
One of the episodes in the Reith Lecture series was about End of Life Issues, which you can hear on the BBC player: stay for the questions at the end - they are interesting. If you prefer to read, the whole episode is transcribed into an 11 page PDF. You know me, I've been jangling the end-of-life I - II - III - IV - V chain before on The Blob. A couple of weeks ago, we were given a copy of Gawande's book Being Mortal, and I finished it a couple of nights ago. It's easy to read, in the same way as Henry Marsh's book about brain surgery, or any book by Gladwell. That doesn't necessarily man that it is easy reading. The book can be characterised as a handful of short stories which have been cunningly interleaved, so that each of the stories is inched forward in each chapter. All of the stories have the same ending, and that's the ending that we can all anticipate in not more than 100 years and probably sooner. The last sentences of the book record the death of Gawande's father, himself a surgeon who was destroyed by a tumour in his neck that invaded his brain and slowly strangled all his vital functions.
"I think he's stopped," I said.
We went to him. My mother took his hand. And we listened, each of us silent.
No more breathes came.
Gawande Sr. died in his own bed at home surrounded by his family, having 'put his affairs in order'. It reads like a good death, but he had spent several years a-dying submitting to an extraordinary range of interventions and only one of his many final carers is named. The others, having been deemed to have failed the old man in care, or honest assessment of odds, or unwillingness to accord him autonomy over his own life have been left anonymous. If this is what can be expected for a fully-insured man of the profession, married to another doctor, father of another, who can network themselves to the very best care and advice that can be found in America, then you may reassess the odds of having a good death, in Kildare or Kiev or Krasnoyarsk. Gawande urges his readers to have the conversation early rather than when it is too late. It is much easier for everyone, except the leading actor and only her when it gets too late, to not have the conversation and just carry on intervening with medical kit until the very last moment. Trying this and that; chemo or radiation; tubes in tubes out; shunts and stents; drugs and drugs and drugs. In the question session at the end of Reith III, Gawande asserts that, in the average lifetime, the most common week to undergo surgery is the last week, and in that week the most common day is the last day. I urge you to get the book out of the library; if your parents are dead, you are next - there are options, it's just that you probably won't be presented with them.
Sunday, 14 August 2016
Colour supplement 140816
Scything clover: wish I could do this
Scything and stooking wheat it's a different stroke
Running the distance:
Mr and Mrs Regan, pensioners of standing, run marathons
Music:
Pekka Kuusisto fiddles and sings at The Proms
Iron & Wine - Cinder and Smoke
Kodaline sing All I want, at Glastonbury
Food-horror:
The Egg Master at the Grauniad
Architectural education:
McMansion 101
Literature:
I tribbed Henry Marsh's book Do No Harm last year. Now you can read a longform chapter.
We were clearing out one of the sheds this weekend and came across a couple of yard-sale books which I'd acquired for the hilarious titles;
Lesbia's Little Blunder by Bessie Marchant. 1st edn Frederick Warne 1934. [cost me 30p] This was Beatrix Potter's [prev] publisher. I don't think it is subconsciously 'gay' the way the Biggles books and supposed to be. But there is plenty of scope for Viz magazine fnarr snk snk leers: There's a Mounty, for instance, and lady called Miss Boosey and "Strange Doings at Spruce Bottom"
"I came on such a queer place," she burst out breathlessly . . . etc. etc.
Almost as exciting is Bully, Fag and Hero by Charles J. Mansford. Publ. Jarrolds 1897. [also cost 30p] Which from the picture on the cover is about schoolboy bondage.
Sunday, 21 July 2019
Sunday Misc 210719
- Florence Foster Jenkins singing for laughs: more people used to laugh at her than with her.
- Mossy Bottom. Advice to people with a fantasy of moving to an Irish small-holding.
- Frightfully English? Follow Max Fosh to Henley or Metal detecting
- France? Jumping the Tour de France on a mountain bike.
- Handling sourdough. High hydration means gloopy and in need of working.
- Food: Did someone mention Jamie "Bust-again" Oliver?
- Drink: The irrepressible Steve Mould on coffee acoustics.
- Acoustics also vital for skating on thin ice.
- Larry Earles Vietnam chopper pilot
- Can you imagine what it was like to be given a lethal toy like that in your 20s? Like my Dad in 1940.
- Trans-Atlantic fibre optic -a comms history.
- Did someone mention Ocean? Cue Nina & Frederick
- A long way from the ocean - Altai throat singing - more Baatyr
- Unstoppable that's what Georgia Shakestaff says [1min] about GirlsUp
- Henry Marsh author [prev] and brain-surgeon being engaging with Jim Al-Khalili
Tuesday, 29 October 2019
Stayin' alive
The CDC says that the Bee-Gees can help you pace your push on your neighbour's chest when s/he's dying. They also say that, for cardiac arrest away from hospital, only 10% survive but that your CPR can up the rate 2- to 3-fold. Reuter's report a more realistic definition of a result that matters: 10% for survival to discharge from hospital. With 350,000 'wild' cardiac arrests in the USA each year, people-power CPR results in 350,000 * (30%-10%) = 70,000 incapacitated extra people alive each year occupying 7% of the 940,000 hospital beds in the country. The UK currently has 160,000 hospital beds [down from 240,000 in 2000!]. Henry "Do No Harm" Marsh [prev] says in his new book [Admissions reviewed later] that 7,000 =4% of those beds are occupied by deeply comatose bodies in a persistent vegetative state. Some of the diverted there from "sucessful" CPR. Proportions will surely be about the same wherever you live. They agree with the figures in UK, where someone floated an annual Restart-a-Heart Day. That concept has gone international and happens in mid-October all over Ireland so you've missed your chance for training this year.
A portable defibrillator can be useful for jolting the heart back to life. Word on the street is that, when someone ran for The Institute's defib during the drama last Tuesday, there was nothing in the box. Someone had "borrowed" it. I hope its hanging in an impoverished GAA club somewhere. An AED Automatic External Defibrillator costs about €1200 in Ireland and there is clearly a buoyant market for this kit; with at least 20 competitively priced brands. All competing for a memorable name too: Philips HeartStart shown R. This guide will help you through the marketing to understand what matters in your purchase. Actually that guide is far too wordy and dense. This one is Irish and easier to read and better focussed.





