I rarely browse in the library because I think that I want to read non-fiction, especially science; but the overwhelming majority of library books are novels. Most pubic libraries are especially thin on the Dewey Decimal 500s (Natural Science and Mathematics). However, we were in the library while awaiting a train, and I noticed the recent acquisitions shelf. I'll have that, I said, when I saw Missing Persons or, My Grandmother's Secrets [2024] by Clair Wills. I also snagged No More Tears [bloboview] to get ahead of the reservation queue.
Wills [R] is about my age. Her mother escaped from a 30 acre farm in West Cork in the 1950s and emigrated to England where she worked as a psychiatric nurse in South London. Some of her uncles joined McAlpine's Fusiliers to dig drains and pour concrete in post-WWII Britain. Like me, every year through her English childhood, Wills and her family went 'home' to Ireland. One difference was that my family were 'shy breeders' so that cousins to hang out with were sparse: only a diminishing store of elderly female relatives who died one after the other as we grew up. In the 1960s a whole lot of history [from last week to last generation] was not in front of the children. And much of this material was known-but-not-spoken.Not murder like in the Case of the Stradbally Postman [whc prev] but othering and exclusion of those who kicked over the traces and got with child. There is a hint of rite-of-passage here, when girls turn ~13 they are inducted into the secrets of those who know. Boys of any age get none of that. And if you're probably gay, like one of the uncles? Not much hope or happiness there. Wills' theory is that attitudes to unwed pregnancies [and the gays] changed for the worse as ALL aspects of social welfare were handed off to The Church in the late 19thC. Before then a) there was nowhere to escape b) communities were kinder and less judgmental. The stranglehold on public morality eased off in the 1970s, although hideous cruelty continued until the end of the 20thC to be habitually meted out on the weak by deeply unhappy spiteful wearers-of-the-cloth. Unmarried mother's allowance (1973) enabled single parents, with some difficulty, to raise children at home rather than in A Home. “The mother of a friend of mine, now in her eighties, who worked for the local county council before she was married, found herself - more than once – filing the admission papers of girls she’d seen at dances a few weeks before”. I didn't have to be like that, and maybe in isolated rural Newfoundland it wasn't.
In a recent interview [60m YT] about the book Clair Wills was asked whether it was 'history' or 'memoir'. A distinction mainly important for those who are shelving or publicizing it. It is, clearly, both. And she is self-aware enough to acknowledge that, because we all mis-remember difficult things, there might be some fiction in the mix. Talking of fiction: further reading in similar issues in West Wexford with Claire Keegan's Small Things Like These [2021 bloboview]. Further reading on the life and early death of Clair Wills Uncles in I could read the sky [1997] by Timothy O'Grady (words) and Steve Pyke (pics) [bloboview]. Mebbe it's time to re-read Saints, scholars, and schizophrenics : mental illness in rural Ireland [1979] by Nancy Scheper-Hughes.
If, like so many Irish families [like mine], yours has mother-and-baby homes looming unspoken in the wings, this book may be too close to the bone. There are several Clair Wills readings, excepts, interviews, reviews on YT and the wider 'net to give you a taster without the full challenging meal.