an old copy of Science and came across some plottable data about the relationship between number of deaths and number of dollars for the ten causes which kill most. The original snippet is paywalled, so you'll have to trust my graph [R]. If life was fair [it's not] or ethics and economics were utilitarian [they could be] these dots should form a straight line: the greatest killers should be whacked with the greatest sack of money. It's reasonably close: the correlation coefficient between the two variables is 0.85 but there are also some notable anomalies.
- The War on Cancer is still being waged, the two biggest killers are "cancer" and heart disease which each take out almost 600,000 Americans each year but cancer gets 2.8x the attention.
- But that's not the greatest discrepancy. $9 gets spent on research for each death from cancer but $12 gets spend for each death from kidney failure and nearly $14 goes to diabetes.
- If you're astute or obsessive you'll notice that there are 11 points on a graph of top ten killers. That's because I've added HIV, research into which gets a handsome $3billlion every year. But, because of a triumphantly successful 30 year research program and the development of anti-retro-viral drugs relatively few people [N = 7000] die of HIV anymore. The inertia in the system, however, continues to devote $430!! to research for each HIV death in the US in 2011.
Although it is American tax-payers who support the US program for HIV/AIDS research, it is perhaps rather blinkered to count just the US impact of this dread disease. On a global perspective, HIV/AIDS killed 1.5 million people in 2012, making it the 6th horseman of the apocalypse, edging infectious diarrhoea to 7th place. Both these killers are falling steadily down the rankings; the former as fancy expensive drugs are getting a better distribution in the third world. Quick quiz: which of the following is not used to treat HIV/AIDS: 3TC ABC AZT DLV ETR FDA FTC NVP SQR TDF?
A. All except FDA - the Food and Drug Administration which oversees the licencing.
To put the 7000 US deaths from HIV/AIDS in perspective, Clostridium difficile infections alone, most acquired in hospitals, kill 7,700 each year. Right at the beginning, between 9,000 and 10,000 children are born with some congenital abnormality and check out before life really starts. But all of these are in ha'penny place compared to Parkinson's [N=25,000] and Liver failure [N=36,000, half of which is alcohol-induced]. Liver disease is of the same order of magnitude as deaths from road-traffic accidents [N=35,000] and fire-arms [N=34,000, of which 11,200 are homicides]. And it's also interesting to note that 30,000 are finished off by falls. If you have elderly parents, this is where you can intervene to help prevent: stairs, trips, trips on stairs, trips over dogs or loose carpets, slips in the bathroom or kitchen. In 2013, 516 US citizens were killed by 'legal intervention'. Which strikes me as rather a low proportion given that 16,000 homicides are perpetrated each year.
Interestingly, according to my source at the CDC, despite obesity being a leading preventable cause of death, nobody dies of this condition. The obese die from diabetes, heart disease, stroke, liver-failure and occasionally from a spectacular fall.