Wednesday, 9 October 2019

Talking up the sludge

Last Friday at The Institute one of my colleagues in Engineering hosted a mini-symposium on sewage sludge: how to process, de-toxify, transport and process the stuff. The event was sponsored by Veolia the French water, waste and energy conglomerate. Sponsorship meant free food; so I was on it like bird shit on a car bonnet. There was a helluva lot of food but really not many people "It's a bit of a niche interest, processed human shit, isn't it", I suggested to the bloke behind me in the auditorium. After I'd grazed for 40 minutes on goujons and chipolatas while chatting to my room-mates, we went in to the first talk . . . by the Sludge Engineer for Irish Water. She had come up from Cork to talk to the very select audience. Even with people who were in the field, she seemed to have an uphill struggle against the perception of sewage sludge as anything other than a toxic liability.

It sounds like it should be a marketable product: rich in phosphates and nitrates, suitable as a soil bulker and conditioner. At least you should be able to give it away for free. My neighbour-above has been [twice] happy to take tonnes of the stuff from the Veolia waste-water treatment plant WWTP in Kilkenny to spread on his fields. Both times delivery-failures up our steep, unpaved dirt-track access has been a disaster for us: one spill and one stuck trailer this summer. It is indicative of the public relations market in sludge that in the first incident the sludge was free but the farmer paid the haulage. 5 years later Veolia is prepared to pay the haulage as well just to get rid of the stuff.  WWTP currently generate 230,000 squidgy tonnes = 60,000 tds [tonnes dry solid] of sludge a year and there really aren't enough people or businesses to take the stuff so some of it gets diverted to landfill.

Stats. There are 500,000 private septic system across the rural Ireland. 60% [N = 376] of Irish WWTPs deal with the sewage from < 500 people. Only 11 plants treat for more than 100,000 p.e. [person equivalents]. Bring back the night-soil men! If we all shit in a bucket we'd waste a lot less water and be more mindful of cleaning up behind ourselves rather than flushing it all away for Nanny State to deal with.

Sewage sludge has a peculiar, particular and persistent smell. That alone makes people think it is a bit fishy. Then there is accumulating data that, apart from NO3- and PO4+, sludge is loaded with cadmium, nickel, microplastics, anti-microbial resistance AMR compounds, unprocessed pharmaceutical residues and, ominously titled, emerging contaminants. aka unknown horrors. The trouble is that ordinary people are as thick as shit in the use of the flush-toilet: wet-wipes and sanitary towels are the least of it. IF the privatised trash collectors start to charge by weight ANDIF people continue to rebel against paying water charges THEN the WWTPs are going to see pizza-crusts, plastic bags, potato peel and holed socks appear for processing.

One thing that emerged from the seminar is that Irish Water's expert on sludge processing was largely at sea when it came to a deep knowledge of the problems associated with its handling and treatment. In the audience were 3 or 4 representatives from the local authority who were responsible for five pilot sewage processing projects involving reed beds. We were presented with an executive summary for where these plants were set up and how they worked. In the post-talk Q&A an old chap on the other side of the room asked why they were using Phragmites australis the common reed and why it had to be imported from Poland . . . Phragmites only grows for six months in every year; there were at least 30 other reed species which grew year-round in the Irish climate. From the public employees, there was no answer at all, let alone a coherent response to this question. The old chap then asked a supplementary question about the complex set of 'aeration' pipe work in the reed-bed: "You are aware that Phragmites is quite content to grow in seriously anaerobic conditions where it is quite capable to finding enough oxygen from the atmosphere?". Pfffffff collapse of stout government-employee parties. Now I'm sure it's more complicated than that, and Irish Water had shelled out wodges of wonga to their own consultants in the design of their reed-beds; but the optics were terrible.

Sewage sludge really needs a public relations campaign to convince us that it is an asset and not a liability. I didn't have the chance to suggest that all Irish Water employees who are pulling in more than €60,000 a year should be obliged to spread at least 60kg of sewage sludge on their gardens [kg pro-rata for higher salaries] - because it is so good for the roses. It is nearly 30 years since the daughter of UK's Minister of Agriculture refused to eat a BSE contaminated beefburger.

Tuesday, 8 October 2019

Whoring for The Man

My working life has been a career only in the sense of an uncontrolled car rushing down a boulder-strewn hillside.
  • Occasional abrupt halts as another spell of retirement [retire early and retire often for sanity and balance] seemed the most sensible option
  • unexpected leaps in my rate of pay - both up and down
  • external circumstances meaning that only part-time was possible
    • I've had five day week, four day weeks andthree day weeks for extended periods
  • a couple of times when I have elected to go on short-pay to gain more time
    • when commuting out of Dublin on Friday became unsupportably inefficient: so I took 80% pay to come home on Thursdays
In 2012 I was down to one day's work a week. I was cash-poor but time rich and me and Dau.II had a regular gig with her grandparents on The Pension Run: taking the elders in to the Post Office for the loot; helping with the groceries; making lunch; mowing the lawn; watching Pointless on the telly; a bit of beach-combing if the tide served; and then home to our own gaff. It was a win win win win arrangement.

Then at the beginning of December in that year, The Institute called to offer me a full-time job starting in the New Year. As you know Dear Reader, I accepted that job and The Blob was born. It is clear from my reading of the entries that it has been a whole lot of fun and I'm glad I took the plunge. But at the time I did the math on the returns for giving up 20 contact hours a week teaching, 20+ other hours preparing for teaching, marking, and attending meetings; several hours a week thinking about work; 7 hours a week driving to and from work in the Yaris. But I did seriously consider whether I would be better off sticking to the one-day job in Dublin where a) the rate of pay as 'Senior Scientist' was much higher than 'Assistant Lecturer' b) the proportion retained after tax and PRSI would be much higher. In purely financial terms it was close. I think, in the end, that I went to The Institute because I'd never done such high intensity teaching before: it was a challenge and tbh I felt I was under-performing in my previous job.

Here's a calculation by Leonard Skinner, who gave up the day job; shed all His Stuff and bought a boat to live on with his partner and two teenaged kids.
His point is that only about 20% of your average working week is going towards the real essentials of food and clothing; the rest is frittered away on stuff, places to hold stuff, heating and lighting for the Stuff Palace; holidays to acquire more stuff. And a crushing amount on the goddamn car to shuttle to work to be able to afford the Stuff Palace. You can read about Leonard's sailing adventures on The Faoin Spéir.

I sent this analysis to one of my ex-students over the weekend. He was the only bloke in my Human Physiology class for Pharmacy Technicians so that's fritzed the sex-ratio entirely . . . insofar as we have a binary sex-ratio anymore. I also sent him links to Ken Robinson on Passion and his book The Element. Dropping out of class partly because of an overwhelming sex-ratio reminded me of my tuthree years as a silver-backed samba drummer. There were very few [old] men in our samba school but loadsa attractive young women. One evening during the tea-break, the other old chap came over with a conspiratorial demeanour to say "It's a wonder more young men don't come here: look at all these fit young wans",



Monday, 7 October 2019

C-sections for all

. . . those who wish to dice with a hospital-acquired infection. The rate of C-section in Ireland, at ~30%, at the high end among Western industrial nations. And it's not a First World solution / problem, Dominican Republic, Brazil, Egypt, Turkey, and Venezuela all have more that 50% of delivery by scalpel. The absolute numbers of caesarian births has doubled since 2000; the rate [12% in 2000 to 21% now] not quite so much because nobody is dying any more and the total population is up 1.5 billion people in that short time. What differ? Labour is so called because it is hard-work: certainly for Mum because she can remember it but it can't be easy for the emergent one, either. If modern tech can bypass the whole messy business and everyone survives, what possible harm?

Well a recent paper in Nature is not beating about the bush [so to speak] Stunted microbiota and opportunistic pathogen colonization in caesarean-section birth in characterising and following up just under 600 full-term babies: 314 vaginal births and 282 C sections.  It's part of the Baby Biome Project BBC; Sanger Centre. The thing is that, unless something has gone seriously wrong there are no bacteria within the amnion - the fluid filled bag in which the foetus develops; obtaining the nutrients to do that development via the placenta and umbilical cord. The mother's skin, her vagina, let alone the nearby rectum (leaking a little as push comes to shove) are, by contrast, home to a rich variety of microbes. Not the same chaps in each niche, however: each place has a characteristic and different family of bacteria.

With an old style vaginal delivery, the new born gets a a good mouthful of his mother's microbial flora, either directly or as soon as he starts sucking his thumb or his mother's breast. Babies delivered by Caesarean section do in deed get a dose of bacteria but they are much more likely to be those typical of hospital acquired infections. The researchers have to an extent controlled for this but the fact that All C-sections are followed by broad-spectrum anti-biotics (as a prophylaxis against infection through the incision) is another variable that drives the neonatal flora towards the bad bacteria. And while I am definitely pro-choice, mothers who plan on a C-section followed by Nestlé powdered cows milk with or without melamine should really read the details of these comparative outcome studies. There is a huge difference in the quality of the child's intestinal flora when measured 4, 7 and 21 days after delivery . . . but when sampled in "infancy" = 9 months later, everything looks like it's evened out between the two modes of appearance:

Sunday, 6 October 2019

Sundata Sixth October

Tech toys and other matter.
Re-use, recycle: "My hotel hack is if you ever need an extra phone charger ask the front desk if they found one. They have a box full."

Saturday, 5 October 2019

Patriarchal foot in mouth

Gawd, he's done it again. It will be a close run thing as to whether I'll be retiring from The Institute next Summer with modest plaudits and accolades OR having my epaulettes ripped off and my USB key broken across the knee of the president of a conduct unbecoming tribunal.

A couple of years ago, after a long day on my feet teaching, I was sitting at a desk in my last class of the day. The students dribbled in from their previous class - their contact hours are on average nearly twice mine. One young woman looked particularly worn out and, in any excess of empathy, I blurted out "Blimey, you looked shagged",  Ooops! Big Red Face: all of my native English speakers will realise that 'shagged' is slang for both "tired" and "bonked".  By context and timing [4PM on a workday afternoon] the former meaning is much more likely but people in my profession have to be above suspicion in their intercourse dialogue with students.

Last Monday [at 4PM! that must be my weirding stupid hour] I had my second remedial math class with this year's intake for our Brewing & Distilling degree. I make it a point of honour to know the names of all my students by the end of the first tuthree weeks of teaching. To facilitate this I strip student ID photos from our server and print them out with names and courses on a single sheet of paper for each class. Sharing this with my colleagues wins many friends. B&D, unsurprisingly, is a really blokey degree; top heavy with mature students with years of experiience making home-brew and making poitin in their several garages. This year we have only one woman in the class. To call the roll, I went round the class as they completed whatever the assignment required, sometimes with confidence and sometimes more tentatively "You're Aaron . . . the other Ahron . . . ?Adam? . . . Alan . . .Aisling, you're easy . . . " STOP right there. No matter the excuse that putting the correct name on the only female in the room is the least hard task for matching faces to names. No teacher can suggest that one of the students is "available".

And because things always go in threes, I had another literal/slang potential miscommunication recently. I was talking to a couple of students who were havering about whether they would do a final-year research project co-supervised by me and someone in The Oak Park campus of Teagasc on the other side of town. That place is 4.5km away = 9 minutes by car but maybe an hour on foot, so I asked the student if she had a car. Ah don't worry about that I'll take a taxi, it's only €8 within the city limits. I've ceased to be amazed at Generations Y & Z who grew up after the Celtic Tiger and think of money as something to be spent. €8 is about what I earned for my first wage packet for a 40 hour week riddling potatoes. I replied "whatever about taxis, it would be a good idea to have a departmental bike" I was going to finish that sentence ". . . so that people can nip across to the other place for a meeting". But the phrase departmental bike seemed to be causing a mild emotional turmoil on the other side of the table. One interpretation, in a wholly different context, could be departmental bike = the available woman. A bike being something you ride which is yet another synonym for bonking. You can't be too careful, I guess. Then again you can't stop talking altogether.

This looks much worse (why is this old buffer continually making inappropriate remarks to young women) than it might be because it's a condensate from about three years of hundreds of interactions that are not actionable. Then again, I would say that wouldn't I? If I had a therapist, I'd ask her if I had a problem.

Friday, 4 October 2019

Doing death right

When my father died in an English hospital in 2001, my brother and I went into the morgue to identify the body . . . because there was an outside chance that the hospital management had got the wrong family linked to the definitely dead corpse in the basement. The Old Man fell backwards down half the flight of stairs on a Sunday night, fracturing a couple of vertebrae, and was blue-lighted to the nearest hospital. Two days later a physiotherapist with a capacious bosom and determined manner attempted to lever him out of bed to do some exercises. The Physio had the right surname but the wrong bed in the wrong ward. She was eventually persuaded to cease-and-desist but never apologised for the additional unnecessary pain the old boy endured under her hands. Every day, sometime twice a day, my mother went in to visit and hear another chapter in a farago of errors, mismanagement, carelessness and disrespect. So it seemed entirely within the bounds of possibility that the other chap (who needed the physiotherapy) was actually dead in the basement while my father was awaiting yer man's CAT scan in Crewkerne, the other hospital in the same NHS Trust.

My brother, who was then flush with money and righteous with resentment, sat my mother down and took notes of the events and time-lines of our father's descent from life to death over 5 days of being ragged around. He sent that summary off to a QC / Senior Counsel with a cheque asking for a full investigation. After several weeks the QC came back to report that my father's medical records had been "lost", so it was hard to get more information than he'd already received from the family. There was a suggestion - and I know this sounds incredible - that he'd been given an insulin injection, went into a coma and died while the care-shift was changing over at the nurses station [he was Type II (late onset, nothing to do with lack of insulin) diabetic]. QC asked did The Brother want to s[p]end another cheque for £10,500 [that's 10,000 guineas because lawyers are old fashioned and like the extra 5%] to take this further? The white heat of indignation had dissipated by then and the answer as No. We all knew that no investigation, no letter of complaint, would bring the Old Man back; but a broadside from a well connected, literate and articulate family might prevent another fellow - poorer, frailer, lonelier - from being subjected to a similar shop of horrors.

Then again, that wasn't the worst death you could imagine. Less than a week from being upright, autonomous, interested and engaged to being flat out and unresponsive on a slab looking curiously like a Roman patrician from the toga-like shift he was rigged up with by the mortuary staff. Angry at the accident and the indignities but not demented; not tooo leaky, managing the pain with stoicism and dignity: gone!

This all re-surfaced for me on Tuesday because I was invited to observe an End-of-Life, How-to seminar in St Luke's Hospital, Kilkenny. This was led by the widow of my late lamented pal Barry who died in that hospital, surrounded by his loving family, from idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis IPF 3.5 years ago.

The saga of his final, drawn-out encounter with the Irish medical machine was a curates egg - good in parts. It reads like that the lower down the medical pecking order an employee of the HSE was the better s/he was at communicating clearly, doing the messy difficult bits cheerfully, and finding time to listen to the patient and his family. The consultant was brusque, secretive, uncommunicative, and certain a) of the diagnosis and b) of the solution. The nurses were uniformly brilliant; two junior doctors and two anaesthetists were able to listen to all the family questions and give information that was useful but neutral - so that Barry could make an informed decision about the medical options.

To the fury of the Consultant, Barry refused intubation and further intervention, requested palliative care only and died a few days later. His family put their heads together to recall and sort out the tangled chain of events and interventions. His widow wrote it all down in a long, articulate, even-handed letter to the hospital's Clinical Director. That man, with remarkable competence and compassion asked her to come visit him to better explain what had gone so wrong on his watch. He also asked if the bereaved would tell her story to that year's crop of medical interns (one year from being full-qualified, autonomous House Officers). Because of my long-standing interest in end of life issues, and because of my mother's recent, not wholly satisfactory, brush with near-death in hospital, I was invited to be a fly on the wall to the third version of what has become an annual fixture at that hospital under than clinical director.

After hearing Barry's tale in some detail, the ClinDir tried to wrap it all up as a short series of life lessons, which he hoped the eight interns would take on board both on his watch and in their later careers in medicine. First it is fair to note that, for every letter of criticism and complain, the hospital receives 7 letters of thanks and commendation.  It's nice to see that people are still prepared to do The Positive.
  • Listen to the patient! Sir Wm Osler, Canadian medical practitioner and philosopher said: "Listen to your patient, they will tell what is the diagnosis".
  • Be respectful
    • of the patient and the family - it's a lot harder for them than it is for you
    • of your medical colleagues - you should continue to listen to alternative explanations from other people even after achieving the dizzying heights of Consultant. 
    • It's important to appreciate and recognise that everyone on the medical team has an essential role and their contributions have to be woven into a complementary skein for the best patient outcomes. Disrespecting The Help will make them clam up and not give their best.
  • Make time to talk - and listen - to the patient and family
  • It's okay if some of the patients die: everyone does that in any case
  • Beware of futility and futile medical interventions
    • They dishonestly raise hopes and expectations
    • They diminsih autonomy
    • Most interventions (devices and pharmaceuticals) have side effects. Does the patient want to lose sphincter control or get splitting head-aches or go out with cracked ribs from a desperate CPR?
    • The cost a lot of money [to the state, the insurer, the family] for minimal benefit (these are, after all, futile interventions that will not significantly increase the length or quality of life)
    • There are opportunity costs too. With only 4 intubation kits available, you really want to think twice before block-booking one for an old chap with fritzed lungs: young mother in emergency admission will be deprived of that potential life-saving tool.
You really need to sort out your advanced health care directives today; lest you find yourself in or beside a hospital bed tomorrow. If you get to the crisis point of a hospital admission you are entitled to be told:
  • what's wrong with at least a differential diagnosis [it could be this, but it's more likely that] preferably with numbers
  • what is going to happen now or in the immediate future [so that the catheter, or the surgical gurney, doesn't come as a total surprise].
  • what is the likely outcome / prognosis
On a related matter, What'sYour Grief has appeared above my notice-horizon. It has a lot of ideas, themes and resources fro coping with loss. I can't relate to much of at all at all; but that's possibly because of my blunted affect or currently ungrieving state.


Thursday, 3 October 2019

Here comes Lorenzo

Storm Lorenzo is heading towards Ireland. There won't be a loaf of bread in any of the shops. With a sense of helpless fascination, I tend to watch incomming storms in real time. Last night Lorenzo was further but fizzier:
His heels have been cooled a good bit by the colder N Atlantic. Is it my imagination or is he going to miss the West coast except for the skirts of his Cloak of Power?
Whatever and however, I've packed my chainsaw into the back of the Yaris is case I have to cut my way through fallen trees back home for my dinner. Go carefully, Irish readers.