For me the interesting parts of science are often prefixed with 'comparative'. I worked through the noughties in a Comparative Immunology lab; Comparative Anatomy gives us the handle on endless forms most beautiful - why, and how, a whale's leg is so different from that of a hippopotamus. Comparative Development tracks through the biological miracle that, although all vertebrates start from a single celled zygote, they all grow up uniquely different from each other. You look more similar to your siblings than to your cousins, David Bowie or Koko the signing Gorilla. Further out we have a lot in common with monkeys, less with dogs and horses and less still with hawks and vultures. In evolutionary terms, some differences are 'trivial' and some profound. Habitat, for example, is not key to understanding where we came from: we have more in common with some flying [bats] and swimming [dolphins] creatures than we do with many terrestrial vertebrates [lizards, ostriches]. It's pretty clear that the ancestral vertebrates developed in the sea and millions of years later one of these creatures crawled ashore and went forth to multiply on dry land. But several times, some of these land-dwellers have reverted to the ancestral location and slipped back into the ocean: whales, seals, penguins, sea-snakes, marine iguanas, manatees. The mammals in the list represent three independent flips back to flipperhood.
I was reflecting on this because of a io9 report of a study investigating the presence of an appendix in a range of mammals. The human appendix is called 'vermiform' because it is a (fat) worm-like appendage to the gut where the small intestine (going down) morphs into the ascending loop of the colon.It is quite variable: effective absent in about 1/100,000 and ranging in size from 2-20cm in length. In some human populations, it tends to sit in front of the gut and in others it is generally tucked behind. For years, the appendix was regarded as a vestigial caecum with no obvious function and an annoying tendency to get inflamed. Appendectomies became routine as soon as minor surgery became safe. Later, larger, epidemiological studies found that an intact appendix conferred some immunological benefit and the rate of whipping the things out declined. Those without an appendix, for example, are more likely to get recurrent Clostridium difficile [prev] infections. About 10 years ago, researchers at Duke U came up with the theory that the appendix was a safe house for 'good' bacteria in the intestinome. After your finely adjusted intestinal flora gets flushed down the toilet with that dodgy curry or is given a good drubbing by a course of antibiotics, then the hold-outs in the appendix come out of the bunker and recolonise the intestine.
The comparative anatomy study is neat because it is real old fashioned science, the researchers gathered truck-loads of data about appendix size and shape, other aspects of the intestine for each species and then information about habitats and feeding habits, food quality, weaning age, and even rates of precipitation. They then lashed all the data into a big digital hopper and shook it to see what correlated with the presence and absence of the appendix. What came out was the observation that the appendix is associated with the caecum! But also associated with the presence of caecal 'lymphoid' tissue. Lymphoid tissue is all about immunity and immune function; which in turn is all about finding an adaptive balance between good and bad microbes. When they dig further they report an inverse correlation between caecum length and habitat breadth . . . but no correlation between appendix length and habitat breadth. They do correct for multiple testing but nevertheless there is no obvious ecological correlate with appendix size which convinces me that we/they have found a 'cause' for the appendix.The paper is also nice because, being published in Comptes Rendus Palevol, all the figure legends are in both English and French. Thus:
contrasts taxa differing in the state of the independent character
un contraste entre taxons différant dans l’état de caractère indépendant
. . . reading scientific French is easy, it's the small words that cause all the problems.
I guess the bottom line is that an appendix can be handy to have in certain circumstances but you're not going to be totally banjaxed if you're missing one. That's what we know from 100 years of human appendectomies and the redundancy seems to be true across a wide range of mammals.
Showing posts sorted by date for query intestinome. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query intestinome. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Thursday, 26 January 2017
Wednesday, 23 November 2016
Umami
I was writing the other day about the new Brewing and Distilling degree, and my Food Fermentation module within it. As this is the first such course and first such module in the country I had to dream up a couple of Text-books. The first (of course) was The Art of Fermenation by Sandor Katz which I came across on our visit to Sherkin last year. The second was Cooked: A Natural History of Transformation by Michael Pollan [Guardian review]. We've met him before on The Blob with his aphorism "Eat food. Mostly plants. Not too much" Hey Cooked is on Netflix, so you don't need to struggle through the book. Or just get it straight from the horse's mouth talking to foodie Googlers.
ANNyway, Cooked. Pollan (four visits to Google; TED talk; at the RSA; Mondavi Center UC Davis) has Harry Pottered himself to the top of the heap of trendy food philosophers. Poor Bill "Heat Braise Shanks" Buford is probably chewing his beard with frustration. Both these books / authors have been successful partly because they are already successful but also because each book has a clearly thought out structure. Buford lays it out explicitly in a far too wordy subtitle ": An Amateur's Adventures as Kitchen Slave, Line Cook, Pasta-Maker, and Apprentice to a Dante-Quoting Butcher". Poor Buford, trained on the job as a journalist and editor on the New Yorker and Granta thought he could do without a ruthless copy-editor on the title. Pollan otoh affects to shoe-horn his extensive musings and experiences in and around the food industry into four parts called Fire, Water, Air and Earth. Those are the four classical 'elements' of Greek cosmogony.
Phew, there is room for my Cook Book which, with devastating clever-clogs-ness, nods towards the Wu Xing with sections called Fire, Water, Earth, Metal and Wood. In it I will cover the essentials of a happy life: rashers, soups, pizza-oven, sharp knives and dull spatulas. Into the section Earth / pizza-oven, I will lurry all the stuff that doesn't fit into the wholly artificial structure suggested by my rather unimaginative publisher.
Now, now Bob enough of your sad-sack sniping at Mr Pollan because people listen to him and ignore you and your thoughts on food engineering and the intestinome. What The Blobbies want to know is if there anything of value in Cooked, because it's coming up for the Xmas book-buy season and they have daughters in the catering trade. Verdict: it's okay, the fact that it's taken me 4 weeks to get through half [Fire, Water] is more to do with falling asleep after dinner and a hard day anticking about while teaching at The Institute.
The book has value if only because it looks in some detail at umami, the fifth chemical class for which we have embedded taste-receptors on our tongues. When I was being educated there were only four: sweet, salt, bitter and sour. Up till this month, I have thought that umami = savouriness = glutamate = MSG which is really far too simplistic analysis. The glutamate angle was revealed by a Japanese biochemist Kikunae Ikeda more that 100 years ago. He noted [1908] that the taste from kombu was distinct from the original four and discovered that it could be purified as the salts of glutamic acid, one of the 20 amino acid building blocks of all proteins. MSG is, of course, mono-sodium glutamate one of those glutamic salts. Ikeda's student and successor Shintaro Kodama isolated [1913] a different chemical from dried bonito flakes, another key ingredient in Japanese cooking, called inosine monophosphate IMP that had umami characteristics. The third element in the troika of taste, guanosine mono-phosphate GMP, had to wait until 1957 to be discovered in shiitake mushrooms by Akira Kuninaka. If guanosine tinkles a bell, it's because it is the G in the ATCG of DNA and the AUCG in RNA, the nucleic acids that carry the genetic information.
It had to wait the bones of another 50 years before we in the West heard about umami to start a raft of trendy eating fads and launch a hundred new restaurants. Of course, like M. Jourdain in Molière's le bourgeois gentilhomme who is surprised and delighted to have been speaking prose for the last 40 years, we have been seeking out and sucking up umami foods since long before the Romans made a batch of fish-sauce or parmesan.
Pollan makes the case that three key ingredients in stock: carrots, onions and celery are the western equivalent of seaweed, fish and mushrooms which perform the complex synergy between three different chemicals to have a positive effect on other dishes. Quoi? I don't believe it, there is no evidence put forward to suggest that carrots are rich in glutamate or inosine. You just have to think parmesan or soy sauce to realise that they don't cut the mustard. There's slightly more evidence to explain the omnipresence of chicken stock [which includes carrot, onion and celery] in french cookery. The result is not really that everything tastes like every night the goddam chicken, no it's more like everything tastes better from being jazzed up by the glutamate in chicken stock.
A large chunk of the Water section of Pollan's book follows him as it masters the art of slow cooking - the braises, the shin of beef, the lamb-shanks. His position is that long slow cooking will not only transform the unchewable fibres of collagen into succulent enriching gelatin but also will reduce the proteins in meat into its component amino acids . . . including glutamate. This means that the ropier cuts of hawg and beef can be rendered into a valuable food source and we don't have to satisfy our desire for meat with expensive chops and steaks.
ANNyway, Cooked. Pollan (four visits to Google; TED talk; at the RSA; Mondavi Center UC Davis) has Harry Pottered himself to the top of the heap of trendy food philosophers. Poor Bill "Heat Braise Shanks" Buford is probably chewing his beard with frustration. Both these books / authors have been successful partly because they are already successful but also because each book has a clearly thought out structure. Buford lays it out explicitly in a far too wordy subtitle ": An Amateur's Adventures as Kitchen Slave, Line Cook, Pasta-Maker, and Apprentice to a Dante-Quoting Butcher". Poor Buford, trained on the job as a journalist and editor on the New Yorker and Granta thought he could do without a ruthless copy-editor on the title. Pollan otoh affects to shoe-horn his extensive musings and experiences in and around the food industry into four parts called Fire, Water, Air and Earth. Those are the four classical 'elements' of Greek cosmogony.
Phew, there is room for my Cook Book which, with devastating clever-clogs-ness, nods towards the Wu Xing with sections called Fire, Water, Earth, Metal and Wood. In it I will cover the essentials of a happy life: rashers, soups, pizza-oven, sharp knives and dull spatulas. Into the section Earth / pizza-oven, I will lurry all the stuff that doesn't fit into the wholly artificial structure suggested by my rather unimaginative publisher.
Now, now Bob enough of your sad-sack sniping at Mr Pollan because people listen to him and ignore you and your thoughts on food engineering and the intestinome. What The Blobbies want to know is if there anything of value in Cooked, because it's coming up for the Xmas book-buy season and they have daughters in the catering trade. Verdict: it's okay, the fact that it's taken me 4 weeks to get through half [Fire, Water] is more to do with falling asleep after dinner and a hard day anticking about while teaching at The Institute.
The book has value if only because it looks in some detail at umami, the fifth chemical class for which we have embedded taste-receptors on our tongues. When I was being educated there were only four: sweet, salt, bitter and sour. Up till this month, I have thought that umami = savouriness = glutamate = MSG which is really far too simplistic analysis. The glutamate angle was revealed by a Japanese biochemist Kikunae Ikeda more that 100 years ago. He noted [1908] that the taste from kombu was distinct from the original four and discovered that it could be purified as the salts of glutamic acid, one of the 20 amino acid building blocks of all proteins. MSG is, of course, mono-sodium glutamate one of those glutamic salts. Ikeda's student and successor Shintaro Kodama isolated [1913] a different chemical from dried bonito flakes, another key ingredient in Japanese cooking, called inosine monophosphate IMP that had umami characteristics. The third element in the troika of taste, guanosine mono-phosphate GMP, had to wait until 1957 to be discovered in shiitake mushrooms by Akira Kuninaka. If guanosine tinkles a bell, it's because it is the G in the ATCG of DNA and the AUCG in RNA, the nucleic acids that carry the genetic information.
It had to wait the bones of another 50 years before we in the West heard about umami to start a raft of trendy eating fads and launch a hundred new restaurants. Of course, like M. Jourdain in Molière's le bourgeois gentilhomme who is surprised and delighted to have been speaking prose for the last 40 years, we have been seeking out and sucking up umami foods since long before the Romans made a batch of fish-sauce or parmesan.
Pollan makes the case that three key ingredients in stock: carrots, onions and celery are the western equivalent of seaweed, fish and mushrooms which perform the complex synergy between three different chemicals to have a positive effect on other dishes. Quoi? I don't believe it, there is no evidence put forward to suggest that carrots are rich in glutamate or inosine. You just have to think parmesan or soy sauce to realise that they don't cut the mustard. There's slightly more evidence to explain the omnipresence of chicken stock [which includes carrot, onion and celery] in french cookery. The result is not really that everything tastes like every night the goddam chicken, no it's more like everything tastes better from being jazzed up by the glutamate in chicken stock.
A large chunk of the Water section of Pollan's book follows him as it masters the art of slow cooking - the braises, the shin of beef, the lamb-shanks. His position is that long slow cooking will not only transform the unchewable fibres of collagen into succulent enriching gelatin but also will reduce the proteins in meat into its component amino acids . . . including glutamate. This means that the ropier cuts of hawg and beef can be rendered into a valuable food source and we don't have to satisfy our desire for meat with expensive chops and steaks.
Sunday, 29 November 2015
Scovilles
When it comes to measuring the whoomph of chili-peppers Capsicum spp. you could crush some up, filter it and run it through an HPLC to determine the precise quantity of capsaicin - 8-methyl-N-vanillyl-6-nonenamide- [structure above] and then say a particular chilli is this hot in moles per gram. It's complicated by the fact that there are several derivatives of the base capsaicin called capsaicinoids which vary as to their pungency. But chili-bums [aka ring-burners?] had developed a comparative scale at least 100 years ago which is independent of HPLC technology. In 1912, a pharmacist called Wilbur Scoville extracted the peppery volatiles by steeping a precise weight of pepper in alcohol. This essence is then serially diluted in a sugar water until half of a panel of expert tasters cannot detect it. This allows a Scoville Heat Unit scale from 0 for regular bell peppers to much more the 1,000,000 SHUs for chilis like the Carolina Reaper, Bhut Jolokia or Naga Viper. That's a measurement of similarity that is fairly well reproducible even if a dimensional analysis [SI Units?] of what you are actually measuring is not possible.
There is a lot of theatricality, not to say machismo, about the consumption of hot peppers as we you can hear with the hilarity off-stage in Good Mythical Morning, [GMM previously]. If that reminds you of Withnail and Matter, I'm with you. That's all mildly interesting . . . not really funny unless you find boxing or cock-fighting [hmmm haven't covered that yet] amusing. What's more interesting is the variability among people as to their capacity to taste/tolerate hot pepper. We had an experiment in this line on a visit to Dublin's Taj Mahal forty years ago.
Metafilter had an interesting compendium recently about 'snacksandsuch' Nate a young feller with a shockin' nonchalance as he chews down on a Chocolate Bhut Jolokia and records his subjective impressions for science. I'm afraid it just made me think of people who wake up from a paracetamol over-dose feeling alright but already doomed to die. But his actions also have a taste of JBS Haldane ruthlessly experimenting on himself for science. If you read the comments on the metafilter post, you'll see that, for several people, chili-chewing is a young man's business. As you pass 30 your tolerance of them changes: not so much in the appetite but in the processing. There is a suggestion that the intestinal flora loses the ability to digest capsaicin as you get older - that's interesting and should be followed up. If your intestinome loses and gains biochemical capability as you age, that may have profound effects in pharmacology. It's sad that Nate adds a note to his Chocolate Bhut Jolokia jaunt "This is my last video. This is because people keep saying my videos are fake." that's a loss for science. But then again, if science post-graduate students burst into tears and went home when a referee dissed their papers, then there would be a lot less science. Then again then again that would possibly be a good thing because 45% of scientific papers have contributed nothing to science. Here's a suggestion that eating chilis burns fat and reduces weight in the obese, young Nate could follow that up and really help his community.
Wednesday, 30 September 2015
It's your gut talking
Back in college, when I was studying genetics before molecular biology had really taken off, we had to do something to fill the curriculum for two years. One of the topics was testing for potential carcinogens in the environment. We knew that one of the causes of cancer was mutations in the genes which stop cells growing when they are crowded up against each out. Without these genes you had uncontrolled growth of cells, which is a pretty good definition of cancer. The way we tested the mutagenicity of stuff [R. Ames Test] was to spread out a 0.1ml drop of concentrated bacteria on a petri dish that contained insufficient nutrients for them to grow. If they did grow, then you could suppose that a mutation had occurred which allowed them to make whatever was missing from the medium. This might occur spontaneously, and with 10 million bacteria in the drop, one of them changing was not impossible; so you needed to run a controlled experiment a) plating out the bacteria on the nutrient-deficient petri-dish and b) plating out the bacteria and a potential mutagen on the nobbled petri-dish. Count the colonies on each plate and do a statistical test and you knew what was mutating bacterial DNA and so what was likely to mutate human DNA . . . and cause cancer. It was a method dreamed up by Bruce Ames at U.Cal Berkeley.
Actually, the Ames Test had an additional layer of complexity. It acknowledged that the liver is the metabolic kitchen of the mammalian body. Loaded with enzymes to cleave this and add that and detoxify the other, the liver will process pretty much any chemical and reduce it to its component parts or at least change it into something different. It could be that some perfectly innocuous additive to Purina Cat Chow was converted into a potent toxin by the cat's liver and it goes blind and dies. So there was a third option in the full Ames test: c) plating out the bacteria and a potential mutagen and an extract of rat liver on the nobbled petri-dish. One of the most startling events of my undergraduate career was adding a drop of own brand Quinnsworth Lemon-Lime shampoo to the Ames test and two days later seeing a constellation of bacterial colonies scattered across the petri dish. That shampoo was a fluorescent lime-green in colour that shouted mutagen quite loudly - that was why we tested it. That was just great - we were doing real science - nobody had done that experiment before and they probably should have done. My other triumph was working through a bomb-scare to see polytene chromosomes.
This all came rushing back to me because of the Nature Supplement on Liver Cancer which I have been reading like a really gripping novel. One of the essays in that compendium is an investigation of the role of the intestinal flora in the cause and cure of liver cancer. That might seem a bit of a long shot, until it's pointed out that everything we eat is taken from the gut up the hepatic portal vein direct to the liver. There are 100 trillion bacteria in your gut of maybe 10,000 different species each containing up to 6000 different genes. That's 60 million potential enzymes for converting harmless substance A into toxic substance B. There is evidence for this quite out-there hypothesis in that rats which are treated with oral antibiotics are less likely to get liver-cancer than reg'lar rats.
Given that observation, any trained scientist will be down in the guts looking for likely suspects for a mechanistic explanation: which chemical A is being converted to which chemical B that is known to be carcinogenic? The accusing finger is currently pointing at deoxycholic acid DCA a "secondary bile salt" not a million miles, chemically, from cholesterol [see R]. The story is that the liver manufactures bile-salts which are stored in the gall-bladder and secreted into the duodenum to help absorb fats. Having done that, the fat is unloaded in the liver and the bile salt is recycled through the gall-bladder. We've met a bile-duct before, getting unblocked. Some of the normal constituents of the intestinome (the gut flora) convert the 'good' bile-acids into DCA which is not only not good, it is positively toxic not only to humans but also to cohorts of other bacteria. It is likely that the DCA-making bacteria benefit from the conversion by creating a bit of lebensraum for themselves by laying a little light holocaust on their neighbours.
That's a story you can tell to Joe Public, untrained in science, as an internally consistent and coherent explanation of what might be actually happening at the interface between the microbiome and the hard-working liver. It's therefore good enough to write a grant application to pull in a $million$ and start investigating how you might be able to put a spanner in the DCA production works. One idea, for example, would be to genetically engineer some street-cleaning bacteria that hoover up DCA and convert it back to bile-acid. That way you leave the intestinome intact and just tweak it to your bidding. Broad-spectrum oral antibiotics really do damage to the delicate balance 'down there' and should only be used as a last resort. FMT fecal-microbiota transplant is one way of delivering bacteria to the dark places to do good works.
Actually, the Ames Test had an additional layer of complexity. It acknowledged that the liver is the metabolic kitchen of the mammalian body. Loaded with enzymes to cleave this and add that and detoxify the other, the liver will process pretty much any chemical and reduce it to its component parts or at least change it into something different. It could be that some perfectly innocuous additive to Purina Cat Chow was converted into a potent toxin by the cat's liver and it goes blind and dies. So there was a third option in the full Ames test: c) plating out the bacteria and a potential mutagen and an extract of rat liver on the nobbled petri-dish. One of the most startling events of my undergraduate career was adding a drop of own brand Quinnsworth Lemon-Lime shampoo to the Ames test and two days later seeing a constellation of bacterial colonies scattered across the petri dish. That shampoo was a fluorescent lime-green in colour that shouted mutagen quite loudly - that was why we tested it. That was just great - we were doing real science - nobody had done that experiment before and they probably should have done. My other triumph was working through a bomb-scare to see polytene chromosomes.
This all came rushing back to me because of the Nature Supplement on Liver Cancer which I have been reading like a really gripping novel. One of the essays in that compendium is an investigation of the role of the intestinal flora in the cause and cure of liver cancer. That might seem a bit of a long shot, until it's pointed out that everything we eat is taken from the gut up the hepatic portal vein direct to the liver. There are 100 trillion bacteria in your gut of maybe 10,000 different species each containing up to 6000 different genes. That's 60 million potential enzymes for converting harmless substance A into toxic substance B. There is evidence for this quite out-there hypothesis in that rats which are treated with oral antibiotics are less likely to get liver-cancer than reg'lar rats.
Given that observation, any trained scientist will be down in the guts looking for likely suspects for a mechanistic explanation: which chemical A is being converted to which chemical B that is known to be carcinogenic? The accusing finger is currently pointing at deoxycholic acid DCA a "secondary bile salt" not a million miles, chemically, from cholesterol [see R]. The story is that the liver manufactures bile-salts which are stored in the gall-bladder and secreted into the duodenum to help absorb fats. Having done that, the fat is unloaded in the liver and the bile salt is recycled through the gall-bladder. We've met a bile-duct before, getting unblocked. Some of the normal constituents of the intestinome (the gut flora) convert the 'good' bile-acids into DCA which is not only not good, it is positively toxic not only to humans but also to cohorts of other bacteria. It is likely that the DCA-making bacteria benefit from the conversion by creating a bit of lebensraum for themselves by laying a little light holocaust on their neighbours.
That's a story you can tell to Joe Public, untrained in science, as an internally consistent and coherent explanation of what might be actually happening at the interface between the microbiome and the hard-working liver. It's therefore good enough to write a grant application to pull in a $million$ and start investigating how you might be able to put a spanner in the DCA production works. One idea, for example, would be to genetically engineer some street-cleaning bacteria that hoover up DCA and convert it back to bile-acid. That way you leave the intestinome intact and just tweak it to your bidding. Broad-spectrum oral antibiotics really do damage to the delicate balance 'down there' and should only be used as a last resort. FMT fecal-microbiota transplant is one way of delivering bacteria to the dark places to do good works.
Friday, 24 October 2014
Wayfinders
I was writing recently about finding where you are on the sea-bed. It's hard to breathe beneath the surface, so you can't stay long, but rocks and roughness are down there which you could recognise if you saw them again. You might, however, be all at sea if you were on the surface, where there seems to be no stable thing - the whole view is either heaving and roiling or a featureless flat calm. But it doesn't have to be like that, and for Polynesian wayfinders it wasn't. They could abstract information from minute clues: a single bird of a particular species, the light reflected on the base of a cloud, the very existence of clouds, tiny differences in the direction of wind and wave - these could all help put them in a known place. MIT's Lily Bui has written recently about how these master navigators did the impossible: they went into the unknown and featureless ocean and came back. A key issue was memory, if you knew all the reaches you had traversed and noted all the changes of direction, all you needed to do was run the program backwards. Which meant that the navigator had to stay awake to record and remember: he was the one with the red eyes. But the knowledge was not lost with the death of one Wayfinder - they could record the key features on stick-charts [R above: showing the essential navigational features of the Marshall Islands] and also they could identify an apprentice who would learn the skills and absorb some of the knowledge by sitting at the feet of the master. Metafilter pointed at a long-form article about the whole business in April 2013. Suck it all up, you'll be amazed! And it's not a dead art, the Hokule'a has been tooling about the Pacific reliably using the old ways for the last several years.
Which brings me to Wade Davis, a Canadian ethnographer who has poured into himself a greater variety of psychotropic vegetable matter than probably any man still walking-and-lucid after these multiple challenges. Read his book One River for an account of the cocktails. Or a Guardian article for the quick version: one concoction requires Banisteriopsis caapi, which contains beta-carbolines and Psychotria viridis, which is loaded with psychotropic dimethyltryptamine (DMT); and it needs them both - either alone is relatively harmless. How many "let's taste this and . . .um . . . that" experiments did it take to find that out?? Davis then wrote a brilliant book called Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom Matters in the Modern World based on his 2009 CBC Massey Lectures. I've lost my copies of both books, so you know what to get me for Christmas . . . along with some humbugs. The Massey Lectures are the Canadian equivalent of the Reith Lectures: a sort of sustained long-form multi-chapter TED talk. Davis uses the Polynesian navigators as a casting off point to recognise that each and every culture on our blue planet has a unique solution to the conundrum is what it means to be human and alive. He's a bit of a celeb is our Wade, not least because he is so articulate and passionate and relentlessly erudite: have a look: I could listen all day. Or Wade interviewed. It is fatuous to say or think that we humans are in some sense 'higher' or better evolved than a dung-beetle or the millions of bacteria which we house in our intestinome. Equally it is hubris and a delusion to think that your culture in Kiev or Glasgow is the smallest bit above that of a walker of songlines in the Australian outback. It is merely a step in another direction. Which is a loaded metaphor because of our embedded certainty that progress is good; there are cultures out there for whom the primary purpose of the practice, lifestyle and ritual is to maintain things exactly as they were at the moment of creation. If we all walk in different ways, and/or stand with Général "J'y suis, j'y reste" MacMahon, we'll cover more ground. Diversity rules, OK!?
Which brings me to Wade Davis, a Canadian ethnographer who has poured into himself a greater variety of psychotropic vegetable matter than probably any man still walking-and-lucid after these multiple challenges. Read his book One River for an account of the cocktails. Or a Guardian article for the quick version: one concoction requires Banisteriopsis caapi, which contains beta-carbolines and Psychotria viridis, which is loaded with psychotropic dimethyltryptamine (DMT); and it needs them both - either alone is relatively harmless. How many "let's taste this and . . .um . . . that" experiments did it take to find that out?? Davis then wrote a brilliant book called Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom Matters in the Modern World based on his 2009 CBC Massey Lectures. I've lost my copies of both books, so you know what to get me for Christmas . . . along with some humbugs. The Massey Lectures are the Canadian equivalent of the Reith Lectures: a sort of sustained long-form multi-chapter TED talk. Davis uses the Polynesian navigators as a casting off point to recognise that each and every culture on our blue planet has a unique solution to the conundrum is what it means to be human and alive. He's a bit of a celeb is our Wade, not least because he is so articulate and passionate and relentlessly erudite: have a look: I could listen all day. Or Wade interviewed. It is fatuous to say or think that we humans are in some sense 'higher' or better evolved than a dung-beetle or the millions of bacteria which we house in our intestinome. Equally it is hubris and a delusion to think that your culture in Kiev or Glasgow is the smallest bit above that of a walker of songlines in the Australian outback. It is merely a step in another direction. Which is a loaded metaphor because of our embedded certainty that progress is good; there are cultures out there for whom the primary purpose of the practice, lifestyle and ritual is to maintain things exactly as they were at the moment of creation. If we all walk in different ways, and/or stand with Général "J'y suis, j'y reste" MacMahon, we'll cover more ground. Diversity rules, OK!?
Friday, 16 May 2014
Metchnikoff
I spent a delightful and informative 20 weeks this year 'teaching' Fermentation and Food Microbiology aka F&F. I say 'teaching' because I was learning at least as much as the students, probably more: I suspect I'd get a pretty good mark on the exams although I was only running one of the 3 lab sections. The point of the course is to get a proper grounding in the bacteria and fungi which either make our food or spoil it according to rather idiosyncratic ideas about what is and is not edible.
Q. Would any properly fastidious person eat Cashel-blue cheese?
A. Not if they put a bit under the microscope!
A chunk of the course dealt with LABs Lactic Acid Bacteria - gram-positive, catalase-negative and are essential to the production of (alphabetically) beer, buttermilk, cheese, cider, cocoa, crème fraîche, kefir, kimchi, koumiss, pickles, quark, sauerkraut, silage, sourdough, wine, yogurt. Hard to live well without them, eh?
Élie Metchnikoff, найрозумніша син з Харкова, whose birthday it is today, was also mad about LABs; having convinced himself that a daily glug of buttermilk was the secret to a long and happy life. It didn't work too good for himself, who was born Илья́ Ильи́ч Ме́чников in 1945 outside Khark{i|o}v in what is now Ukraine and died at the age of 71. I've called him the Smartest Son of Kharkiv above but he would probably have preferred умный сын Харькове as he grew up speaking Russian and didn't hang around in Kharkiv for long. He only stayed long enough to get his degree in Natural Sciences from Харківський університет before heading out into the world as a travelling researcher working in Heligoland, Giessen, Göttingen, München, Одесса/Одеса/Odessa, Санкт-Петербург, Messina, and finished up in Paris working with Louis Pasteur, where we see him looking haggard after a long session with the microscope - an essential item in his toolkit.
While he was working is Giessen as a young chap he noted a single cell in a flatworm engulfing and digesting a foreign particle. It was an inspiring revelation for him that informed a large part of his later research - the part that led to him sharing the 1908 Phys/Med Nobel Prize. In Messina several years later, working on microscopic starfish larvae, he again noted phagocytosis: he famously annoyed his experimental subjects by poking them with rose-thorns and watched as specific starfish cells mobilised to deal with the invasion. He realised that this must be the purpose of our own white blood cells. He wasn't by any means the first to notice this, but everyone else thought of the mobilisation of WBCs as the explanation of how disease and septicaemia rapidly gets propagated through the body. As an early reader of, and inspired by, Darwin's Origin of Species, he knew that this was a crap, partial, inadequate explanation of the proximate phenomenon without thinking further to the ultimate, evolutionary purpose of such a widespread phenomenon. It's a bit like Lavoisier turning the theory of phlogiston on its head to show what actually happened when things burn.
Pasteur, for example, greeted the Metchnikoff theories with skepticism, as did Behring (Nobel Prize for Phys/Med in 1901) . But it turned out that, according to today's truth, Metchnikoff was correct. He was probably also correct about the importance of the intestinal microflora in our health and happiness. Metchnikoff died in 1916, and his ideas about chugging down a few billion LABs for breakfast were and are looked at as cranky and obsessive. But one thing is for sure, you've got to take a lot of bacteria to make a difference to the intestinome, which is composed of 200 trillion cells in perhaps 10,000 different species. A few years ago, Danone, started to market a teeny-tiny bottle of yoghurt as Actimel at an inflated price because it contained some "Lactobacillus casei Defensis or Immunitas" whoowah! - must be good for you it's called goodforyouitas. Most of the bugs in Actimel are Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus salivarius = yoghurt.
There's another interesting immuno-story in the blogosphere (Kottke for example) this week picking up from a report in WashPost. It's only a sample of one. Worse than that, it's a sample of two with a success rate of 50% but Stacy Erholtz appears to have been cured of a fearsome metastasizing myeloma cancer. One of the human aspects of the story is that Ezholz metastases included a gross tumour on her forehead that was pushing both outwards and into her brain. Her kids had christened this maternal appendage "Eric". The medicos at the Mayo Clinic elected, as a last ditch push, to inject Erholz with 100 billion units of measles virus rather than using them to innoculate 10 million children against this serious childhood illness. They were probably close to their sell-by-date so would have been flushed anyway. That's a lot of virus and they thought it was going to take an hour to infuse it all. Within a few minutes of the start of treatment, Ezholz reported a splitting headache and the medicos must have worried that something Northwick was about to occur but their patient was damned if they didn't persist, so they did. An hour after infusion finished, her temperature was up to gasket-blowing, and she was shaking and vomiting. It was too late to do anything then except wrap up the patient and wait. Two days later it was clear that Evan was shrinking away and over the next few weeks the measles virus hunted out and mopped up all the tumour cells. Makes you think about interventions in the delicate balance between the microbes and the immune system: C.diff; Augmentin; Tamiflu etc etc.
ANNyway it's Élie's birthday today, he was a man who made a difference: by making some careful observations and reaching some not-so-obvious-to-all-thinking-people conclusions.
будь ласка, видаліть ваші капелюхи.
Q. Would any properly fastidious person eat Cashel-blue cheese?
A. Not if they put a bit under the microscope!
A chunk of the course dealt with LABs Lactic Acid Bacteria - gram-positive, catalase-negative and are essential to the production of (alphabetically) beer, buttermilk, cheese, cider, cocoa, crème fraîche, kefir, kimchi, koumiss, pickles, quark, sauerkraut, silage, sourdough, wine, yogurt. Hard to live well without them, eh?
Élie Metchnikoff, найрозумніша син з Харкова, whose birthday it is today, was also mad about LABs; having convinced himself that a daily glug of buttermilk was the secret to a long and happy life. It didn't work too good for himself, who was born Илья́ Ильи́ч Ме́чников in 1945 outside Khark{i|o}v in what is now Ukraine and died at the age of 71. I've called him the Smartest Son of Kharkiv above but he would probably have preferred умный сын Харькове as he grew up speaking Russian and didn't hang around in Kharkiv for long. He only stayed long enough to get his degree in Natural Sciences from Харківський університет before heading out into the world as a travelling researcher working in Heligoland, Giessen, Göttingen, München, Одесса/Одеса/Odessa, Санкт-Петербург, Messina, and finished up in Paris working with Louis Pasteur, where we see him looking haggard after a long session with the microscope - an essential item in his toolkit.
While he was working is Giessen as a young chap he noted a single cell in a flatworm engulfing and digesting a foreign particle. It was an inspiring revelation for him that informed a large part of his later research - the part that led to him sharing the 1908 Phys/Med Nobel Prize. In Messina several years later, working on microscopic starfish larvae, he again noted phagocytosis: he famously annoyed his experimental subjects by poking them with rose-thorns and watched as specific starfish cells mobilised to deal with the invasion. He realised that this must be the purpose of our own white blood cells. He wasn't by any means the first to notice this, but everyone else thought of the mobilisation of WBCs as the explanation of how disease and septicaemia rapidly gets propagated through the body. As an early reader of, and inspired by, Darwin's Origin of Species, he knew that this was a crap, partial, inadequate explanation of the proximate phenomenon without thinking further to the ultimate, evolutionary purpose of such a widespread phenomenon. It's a bit like Lavoisier turning the theory of phlogiston on its head to show what actually happened when things burn.
Pasteur, for example, greeted the Metchnikoff theories with skepticism, as did Behring (Nobel Prize for Phys/Med in 1901) . But it turned out that, according to today's truth, Metchnikoff was correct. He was probably also correct about the importance of the intestinal microflora in our health and happiness. Metchnikoff died in 1916, and his ideas about chugging down a few billion LABs for breakfast were and are looked at as cranky and obsessive. But one thing is for sure, you've got to take a lot of bacteria to make a difference to the intestinome, which is composed of 200 trillion cells in perhaps 10,000 different species. A few years ago, Danone, started to market a teeny-tiny bottle of yoghurt as Actimel at an inflated price because it contained some "Lactobacillus casei Defensis or Immunitas" whoowah! - must be good for you it's called goodforyouitas. Most of the bugs in Actimel are Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus salivarius = yoghurt.
There's another interesting immuno-story in the blogosphere (Kottke for example) this week picking up from a report in WashPost. It's only a sample of one. Worse than that, it's a sample of two with a success rate of 50% but Stacy Erholtz appears to have been cured of a fearsome metastasizing myeloma cancer. One of the human aspects of the story is that Ezholz metastases included a gross tumour on her forehead that was pushing both outwards and into her brain. Her kids had christened this maternal appendage "Eric". The medicos at the Mayo Clinic elected, as a last ditch push, to inject Erholz with 100 billion units of measles virus rather than using them to innoculate 10 million children against this serious childhood illness. They were probably close to their sell-by-date so would have been flushed anyway. That's a lot of virus and they thought it was going to take an hour to infuse it all. Within a few minutes of the start of treatment, Ezholz reported a splitting headache and the medicos must have worried that something Northwick was about to occur but their patient was damned if they didn't persist, so they did. An hour after infusion finished, her temperature was up to gasket-blowing, and she was shaking and vomiting. It was too late to do anything then except wrap up the patient and wait. Two days later it was clear that Evan was shrinking away and over the next few weeks the measles virus hunted out and mopped up all the tumour cells. Makes you think about interventions in the delicate balance between the microbes and the immune system: C.diff; Augmentin; Tamiflu etc etc.
ANNyway it's Élie's birthday today, he was a man who made a difference: by making some careful observations and reaching some not-so-obvious-to-all-thinking-people conclusions.
будь ласка, видаліть ваші капелюхи.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




